Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Stainless vs Plastic Feed Pan: Which One Should You Buy?

Stainless vs plastic feed pan compared on durability, cleaning, weight and capacity, with figures from stainless steel bowl and pan listings.

Stainless vs Plastic Feed Pan: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1AASPIRE PETS 9 Quart Stainless Steel Flat Side BucketAASPIRE PETS 9 Quart Stainless Steel Flat Side Bucket9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Little Giant Plastic Utility PanLittle Giant Plastic Utility Pan9.5/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Little Giant Galvanized Utility PanLittle Giant Galvanized Utility Pan9.5/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Little Giant® Plastic Utility PanLittle Giant® Plastic Utility PanView on Amazon
  5. 54 Pack Rubber Feed Pan4 Pack Rubber Feed PanView on Amazon
  6. 66Pcs Rubber Feed Pan6Pcs Rubber Feed PanView on Amazon
  7. 74Pcs Rubber Feed Pan4Pcs Rubber Feed PanView on Amazon
  8. 82Pcs Rubber Feed Pan2Pcs Rubber Feed PanView on Amazon
  9. 9Rubbermaid Commercial Products Brute Animal Pan FeederRubbermaid Commercial Products Brute Animal Pan FeederView on Amazon

The stainless vs plastic feed pan question comes down to this: stainless steel pans last longer, resist chewing and go in the dishwasher, while plastic pans weigh less and cost less up front but crack and get chewed sooner. For goats, which push, step on and chew everything, stainless steel usually wins on lifespan. Every number below comes from a stainless steel bowl or pan listing we compared; the plastic side has no matching figures in these listings, so we describe plastic without numbers.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Stainless vs plastic feed pan: the short answer

Choose stainless steel if the pan lives in the pen full time, if your goats chew, or if you want dishwasher cleaning. Choose plastic if the pan is a light-duty backup, if you carry feed a long way and want the lightest pan, or if you plan to replace pans often. Stainless listings publish capacities from 0.85 gallon to 3 gallons and dimensions for every size; plastic pans in this comparison publish no matching figures, so compare them in person.

If you want scored picks instead of a material guide, our best feed pan for goats roundup compares five pans.

Material Example reference listing Stated capacity Cleaning Weight
Stainless steel GIXSEGIE 1.25 gallon bowl 1.25 gallons (4731 ml) Dishwasher safe 15.52 ounces
Stainless steel Ohtomber 0.85 gallon bowl 0.85 gallon (3217 ml) Dishwasher safe 10.23 ounces
Stainless steel Ohtomber 1.25 gallon bowl 1.25 gallons (4731 ml) Dishwasher safe 14.89 ounces
Stainless steel Lonepetu 3 gallon bowl 3 gallons (11,356 ml) Hand wash, per spec table 1.54 pounds
Stainless steel Kichwit 1.8 gallon bowl 1.8 gallons Dishwasher, per bullets 1.1 pounds
Plastic No reference listing here Not stated Not stated Not stated

Durability: chewing, kicking and stepping

Stainless steel wins on durability in the listings. The Ohtomber listing says its stainless bowls will not become brittle over time or break easily, unlike plastic or ceramic. The Lonepetu listing says its bowl is thicker than a normal dog bowl, which makes it less likely to be kicked over, and gives 1.54 pounds for the 3 gallon size. Goats chew pan edges, stand in pans and knock them around, so a pan that does not crack matters more than one that is light.

Plastic pans crack, especially in cold weather and under chewing. A chewed plastic edge also gives bacteria a place to hide that scrubbing cannot reach. If you use plastic, plan to replace the pan when the edge roughens or the bottom cracks, and keep a spare on hand.

Cleaning: dishwashers and smooth surfaces

Stainless listings are explicit about cleaning. The GIXSEGIE listing says its 1.25 gallon bowl is dishwasher safe with a smooth interior surface that is easy to clean by hand. The Ohtomber listings for the 1.25 gallon and 0.85 gallon bowls both say dishwasher safe. The Kichwit listing says its 1.8 gallon bowl is easy to clean in the dishwasher. The YUDANSI 10.2 inch bowl listing says the bowls only need to be washed with water and come out as bright as new, and the 13.3 inch YUDANSI bowl listing says hand wash only in its spec table, so check the care line on your exact size.

Plastic is harder to sanitize once it is scratched. Feed oils and mineral dust work into scratches and do not rinse out the way they do from a smooth steel surface. If you feed wet feed or minerals in a plastic pan, wash it more often and retire it when the surface turns rough.

Weight and stability

Stainless pans are heavy enough to stay put. The GIXSEGIE 1.25 gallon bowl weighs 15.52 ounces at 12.6 x 8.7 x 4 inches, and the Ohtomber 1.25 gallon bowl weighs 14.89 ounces at 12.4 x 8.46 x 3.94 inches. The smaller Ohtomber 0.85 gallon bowl weighs 10.23 ounces at 12.4 x 8.46 x 2.76 inches. The Kichwit 1.8 gallon bowl weighs 1.1 pounds at 14 x 10.5 x 4 inches. That weight, plus wide rectangular footprints, is what keeps a pan from sliding when a goat pushes it.

Plastic pans are lighter, which helps when you carry feed across the pasture, but a light pan slides and tips more easily. If you feed on the ground rather than in a rack, weight is stability, and stainless has the advantage.

Size and capacity

Stainless listings give exact capacities. The range in our reference listings runs from 0.85 gallon (3217 ml) on the small Ohtomber bowl, through 1.0 liter (35 oz) on the YUDANSI 10.2 inch bowl and 1.5 liters (53 oz) on the YUDANSI 13.3 inch bowl, to 1.25 gallons (4731 ml) on the GIXSEGIE and large Ohtomber bowls, 1.8 gallons on the Kichwit bowl and 3 gallons (11,356 ml) on the Lonepetu bowl. Footprints run from 12.4 x 8.46 inches up to 14 x 10.5 inches.

Match the pan to the job: a 1 to 1.5 liter pan suits a single goat or a kid, while a 1.8 to 3 gallon pan suits a group or a full day of feed. Plastic pans rarely publish this level of detail in the listings we see, so measure the pan in the store and compare it against these stainless figures.

Food-grade materials

Several stainless listings state food-grade material outright. The GIXSEGIE listing says food-grade stainless steel. The Lonepetu listing says food-grade stainless steel and mirror-polished. The Kichwit listing says food grade stainless steel with rolled edges and a smooth finish. The Winco steam table pan listing says 25 gauge 18/8 stainless steel and NSF listed, at 10.5 x 6.38 x 2.5 inches. That paper trail is the point: with stainless you can read the grade and the certification on the listing.

Plastic pans vary. Some are food-grade and some are not, and the listing does not always say which. If you buy plastic, look for a food-grade marking on the pan itself, and avoid pans with a strong chemical smell out of the package.

What the listings leave unclear

These reference listings are dog bowls and foodservice pans, not goat feed pans, so apply their figures as material evidence, not as goat-specific advice. None of them states a warranty for farm use. The GIXSEGIE spec table lists 3.2 gallons of capacity against 1.25 gallons in the bullets, so read both before trusting a number. And no plastic pan listing appears in this reference set at all, which is itself a finding: stainless makers publish more figures than plastic makers do.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers pan material only. It does not cover how much feed a goat needs, feed types or any health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about rations and goat health.

FAQs from goat keepers

Is a stainless steel feed pan better than plastic for goats?

Usually, yes. Stainless resists chewing, does not become brittle over time and goes in the dishwasher, per the Ohtomber and GIXSEGIE listings. Plastic is lighter and cheaper up front but cracks and gets chewed sooner.

What size feed pan do I need for goats?

Stainless reference listings run from 1.0 liter (35 oz) to 3 gallons (11,356 ml). A 1 to 1.5 liter pan suits a single goat, while 1.8 to 3 gallons suits a group. Match the footprint, from 12.4 x 8.46 inches up to 14 x 10.5 inches, to your feeder or rack.

Can I put a stainless feed pan in the dishwasher?

The GIXSEGIE 1.25 gallon, both Ohtomber bowls and the Kichwit 1.8 gallon listings say dishwasher safe. The YUDANSI 13.3 inch listing says hand wash only in its spec table, so check the care line on your exact pan.

Do plastic feed pans hold odors?

They can once scratched. Feed oils work into scratches and do not rinse out the way they do from the smooth, mirror-polished stainless the Lonepetu and GIXSEGIE listings describe. Wash plastic pans often and retire them when the surface turns rough.

More from the barn

See every feed pan guide and all feeding and water guides.

More picks: best feed pans for goats, rubber vs plastic feed pan, feed pans with handles and feed pans for messy eaters.