Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Aluminum vs Steel Fence Wire: Which One Suits a Goat Fence?

Aluminum or steel fence wire for goats? Conductivity, weight, rust and strength compared from wire listings, plus the contradictions to watch.

Aluminum vs Steel Fence Wire: Which One Suits a Goat Fence?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Aclastool Electric Fence WireAclastool Electric Fence Wire9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Zareba 17 Gauge Aluminum Wire for Electric FencingZareba 17 Gauge Aluminum Wire for Electric FencingView on Amazon
  3. 3Zareba Fi-Shock 17 Gauge Aluminum Wire for Electric FencingZareba Fi-Shock 17 Gauge Aluminum Wire for Electric FencingView on Amazon
  4. 416-Guage Aluminum Wire16-Guage Aluminum WireView on Amazon
  5. 5Aluminum Electric Fence Wire for Garden FenceAluminum Electric Fence Wire for Garden FenceView on Amazon
  6. 617 Gauge Aluminum Electric Fence Wire 1312ft for Garden &17 Gauge Aluminum Electric Fence Wire 1312ft for Garden &View on Amazon
  7. 717 Gauge Aluminum Electric Fence Wire 250ft for Garden &17 Gauge Aluminum Electric Fence Wire 250ft for Garden &View on Amazon

The aluminum vs steel fence wire question comes down to what you value more: aluminum is lighter, conducts electricity better and does not rust, while steel is stronger and heavier and needs a coating to fight rust. For electric fences around goats, aluminum is the common choice because conductivity matters more than raw strength; for permanent high-tension fences, steel’s strength wins. Every number below comes from an aluminum wire listing we compared; the steel side is explained without numbers.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Aluminum vs steel fence wire: the short answer

Choose aluminum wire for electric fences: the listings state it conducts better than steel, weighs far less and will not rust, which makes long runs easier to install and maintain. Choose steel for non-electric permanent fences where maximum strength and resistance to stretching matter most. If you are building an electric fence for goats, aluminum is the wire the listings are made for.

What aluminum fence wire offers

All the reference listings are aluminum, and they agree on the core points:

  • Conductivity: the Fi-Shock listings state aluminum conducts electricity 4 times better than steel. The AgriOtter listing states up to 40 percent better conductivity than steel. Both are maker claims; the multipliers differ, which we flag in “Read the listing twice” below.
  • Weight: the Field Guardian listing states its aluminum wire is a third the weight of steel, and the AgriOtter listing states 66 percent lighter than steel. A 250 ft spool of 17 gauge wire like the HIBUMFX or HENGTONG AW-76 is easy to carry and unspool by hand.
  • Rust: the Fi-Shock, HENGTONG, HIBUMFX and MOEUFFIR listings state the wire does not rust, which matters for fences left out in all weather.
  • Strength: the Fi-Shock, HENGTONG, HIBUMFX and MOEUFFIR 17 gauge listings state 38,000 PSI tensile strength with a 90 lb breaking load. The Field Guardian 16 gauge listing states 139 lb tensile strength. The Blulu 14 gauge listing, an aluminum magnesium alloy, states 260 MPa tensile strength.
  • Gauges and lengths: the listings run from 14 gauge (2.0 mm) down to 17 gauge, on spools from 250 ft to 1640 ft, with 1/4 mile spools from Fi-Shock, Field Guardian, AgriOtter and HENGTONG. The SparkSway listing is 11 gauge fence ties for chain link, a different job from electric fence wire.

Aluminum is also easier to work by hand: the Field Guardian listing notes greater flexibility than steel wire that can be hand twisted and tied, and several listings mention running the wire straight off the spool.

What steel fence wire offers

No steel wire appears in the reference listings, so there are no figures to quote here. Steel’s advantages are strength and stiffness: it resists stretching under tension and holds up where animals lean, rub or push on the fence. Its drawbacks are weight, which makes long runs harder to handle and puts more load on posts, and rust: plain steel wire corrodes outdoors unless it is galvanized or otherwise coated. Steel also conducts electricity less well than aluminum, so it is a weaker choice for the hot wires of an electric fence. Galvanized high-tensile steel is the standard for permanent woven and barbed fences rather than for electric strands.

Comparing the metals

Factor Aluminum wire Steel wire
Conductivity Better; Fi-Shock states 4x better than steel, AgriOtter states up to 40 percent better Lower than aluminum
Weight Lighter; Field Guardian states a third the weight of steel Heavier; harder to handle on long runs
Rust Stated rust-proof by several makers Rusts unless galvanized or coated
Strength 38,000 PSI and 90 lb breaking load on the 17 gauge listings Stronger and stiffer; resists stretching
Workability Flexible; hand twisted and tied per the Field Guardian listing Stiffer; harder to bend by hand
Best use Electric fence strands Permanent non-electric fences

Read the listing twice

Wire listings mostly agree, but a few details deserve a second look:

  • Conductivity multipliers: Fi-Shock states aluminum conducts 4 times better than steel, while AgriOtter states up to 40 percent better. These are different makers’ claims, not a single measured standard, so treat the direction (aluminum conducts better) as solid and the exact multiplier as marketing.
  • Field Guardian length: the title says 1/4 mile, but the spec table lists 1312.3 feet, which is slightly under a 1/4 mile (1320 feet). Plan the run with the smaller figure.

Also note the SparkSway listing is fence ties for chain link, not electric fence wire, so its 11 gauge figure does not compare with the 14 to 17 gauge electric strands.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers wire metal only. It does not cover chargers, insulators or grounding; see our electric fence chargers for goats and fence insulator guides for those. We also do not cover poly wire or poly tape; our best poly wire for goats roundup compares polywires.

FAQs from goat keepers

Is aluminum or steel wire better for an electric goat fence?

Aluminum. The listings state better conductivity than steel, lighter weight and no rust, and electric fences depend on conductivity. Steel suits permanent non-electric fences.

Does aluminum fence wire rust?

The Fi-Shock, HENGTONG, HIBUMFX and MOEUFFIR listings state their aluminum wire does not rust. Steel wire needs a galvanized or coated finish to resist rust.

How strong is 17 gauge aluminum fence wire?

The 17 gauge listings from Fi-Shock, HENGTONG, HIBUMFX and MOEUFFIR state 38,000 PSI tensile strength with a 90 lb breaking load.

What spool lengths do aluminum fence wire listings offer?

The listings range from 250 ft spools to 1640 ft, with 1/4 mile spools from Fi-Shock, Field Guardian, AgriOtter and HENGTONG. The Field Guardian 1/4 mile spool lists 1312.3 feet in its spec table.

Can I twist aluminum fence wire by hand?

The Field Guardian listing notes greater flexibility than steel wire and says it can be hand twisted and tied. Several listings describe running the wire straight off the spool.

More from the barn

See every goat fencing wire guide and all fencing and shelter guides.

More picks: best poly wire for goats, barbed wire vs electric fence, best poly tape for electric fence and corner post vs line post insulators.