Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Bell Boots vs Hoof Boots: Which One Should You Buy?

Bell boots compared on material, closure and stated size, with the missing hoof boot side explained so you can choose the right protection.

Bell Boots vs Hoof Boots: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Horse Hoof Thrush Treatment ClayHorse Hoof Thrush Treatment Clay9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Abbylike Bell Boot for Horse 1 Pair/2 Pair AvailableAbbylike Bell Boot for Horse 1 Pair/2 Pair AvailableView on Amazon
  3. 3Shires Arma Overreach Fleece Bell BootsShires Arma Overreach Fleece Bell BootsView on Amazon
  4. 4Shires ARMA Fleece Overreach Bell BootsShires ARMA Fleece Overreach Bell BootsView on Amazon
  5. 5Tough 1 Basic Ribbed Rubber Bell BootsTough 1 Basic Ribbed Rubber Bell BootsView on Amazon
  6. 6Tough1 No Turn Bell BootsTough1 No Turn Bell BootsView on Amazon
  7. 7CASHEL Bell Boots RubberCASHEL Bell Boots RubberView on Amazon

A horse that overreaches can clip the back of a front hoof with a hind hoof, and the bell boots vs hoof boots question starts right there, because each kind of boot covers different ground. The bruise lands on the heel bulbs and the coronary band, the soft ring where hoof meets hair, and a bell boot wraps the front hoof to cover exactly that ground. The listings in this guide are all bell boots, and no hoof boot appears among them, so this guide compares the bell boots on stated material, closure and size, and explains the hoof boot side from what the bell boot listings state, so you can tell which kind of protection fits the job.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Bell boots vs hoof boots: the short answer

A bell boot wraps the front hoof and covers the coronary band and heel bulbs against overreaching and interference, while a hoof boot covers the whole hoof. Pick a bell boot when the job is guarding the heel and coronary band of a front hoof, and look for a hoof boot when the job is covering the whole hoof. The listings here give a choice among bell boots only: rubber pull-on pairs from Harrison Howard in Black and Violet, a ballistic overreach boot from Professional’s Choice, and a rubber pair from Abbylike, each in Large or X-Large.

The bell boots in this guide

Boot Material Closure Stated size
Harrison Howard pull-on bell boots, Black Rubber Leather touch-close tape Large
Harrison Howard pull-on bell boots, Violet Rubber Leather touch-close tape Large
Professional’s Choice ballistic overreach bell boots Textured PVC outer, neoprene interior Hook and loop Large
Abbylike rubber bell boots Rubber Not stated X-Large

Harrison Howard rubber pull-on bell boots

The Harrison Howard pair lists extra thick rubber, a smooth interior, and fine stripes on the exterior that add thickness and stand up to collisions and impacts. The maker lists 360-degree coverage around the front hoof, covering the coronary band and heel bulbs, and a large leather touch-close tape that makes the boot easy to put on and keeps it in place. The pair comes in Black and Violet, each in Large, and ships as a 2-pack. The maker lists the rubber as waterproof and built to stand up to wear.

Professional’s Choice ballistic overreach bell boots

The Professional’s Choice boot lists a textured PVC outer layer, a neoprene interior that absorbs shock, and a soft lycra lining that prevents rubbing. The hook and loop closure wraps on fast, and the maker lists the boot as sold in pairs in Large, with stated dimensions of 7.0 inches by 6.0 inches by 6.0 inches and a stated weight of 0.4 pounds. The maker lists no warranty term for this boot.

Abbylike rubber bell boots

The Abbylike pair lists quality rubber that is soft, flexible and easy to clean, with 360-degree protection for the front hoof. The ankle part measures about 3.39 inches in diameter and the boot height is 3.9 inches, so measure the hoof before ordering. The pair comes as 1 pair of 2 pieces in X-Large and Black, and the maker lists the boots as suited to competition and training.

Bell boots: what they cover

The maker describes 360-degree coverage that wraps around the front hoofs and covers the coronary band and heel bulbs, the areas at risk from overreaching and interference. The Harrison Howard and Abbylike pairs state that coverage in plain terms, and the Professional’s Choice boot states the same job with a textured PVC outer layer that guards against interference and overreaching. A bell boot sits over the front hoof and leaves the rest of the leg open, which is why the fit around the heel matters more than the length of the boot.

Hoof boots: what this guide does not show

No hoof boot appears in the listings for this guide, so no hoof boot is compared here. A hoof boot covers the whole hoof rather than the heel and coronary band alone, which is a different job from the overreach protection these bell boots provide. For the other side of the comparison, see the hoof boots vs horseshoes guide. Readers who need a hoof boot should look for a listing that states the whole-hoof coverage, the closure and the size range, and compare those stated figures the same way this guide compares the bell boots.

How to choose bell boots vs hoof boots

Start with the job

When the job is guarding the heel bulbs and coronary band of a front hoof against overreaching, a bell boot fits. When the job is covering the whole hoof, a hoof boot is the kind to look for, and this guide has no hoof boot listing to compare. The best horse hoof boots roundup compares hoof boots on their own terms.

Match the closure to the routine

The Harrison Howard pair uses a large leather touch-close tape, and the Professional’s Choice boot uses hook and loop. A tape or hook and loop closure comes off and goes on without pulling the boot over the hoof, while a pair with no stated closure needs a closer look at the fit before ordering. The Abbylike pair states no closure type, so measure the hoof and match the stated size before ordering.

Check the stated size

The Harrison Howard pairs and the Professional’s Choice boot are stated in Large, and the Abbylike pair is stated in X-Large. The maker lists the Abbylike ankle part at about 3.39 inches in diameter and the boot height at 3.9 inches, and the Professional’s Choice boot at 7.0 inches by 6.0 inches by 6.0 inches and a weight of 0.4 pounds. Measure the hoof and match the stated size before ordering.

Material and care

Rubber, textured PVC with a neoprene interior, and a soft lycra lining are the materials the makers list. The Harrison Howard rubber is stated as waterproof, and the Abbylike rubber is stated as easy to clean and maintain. A smooth interior and a lining that prevents rubbing matter for comfort over a long day in the stall or the field.

FAQs from goat keepers

What is the difference between bell boots and hoof boots?

A bell boot wraps the front hoof and covers the coronary band and heel bulbs against overreaching. A hoof boot covers the whole hoof. The listings in this guide are bell boots only.

Do bell boots come in pairs?

The Harrison Howard pair ships as a 2-pack, the Abbylike pair comes as 1 pair of 2 pieces, and the Professional’s Choice boot is sold in pairs. Check the stated pack count before ordering.

What size bell boot should I order?

The Harrison Howard pairs and the Professional’s Choice boot are stated in Large, and the Abbylike pair is stated in X-Large. The maker lists an Abbylike ankle diameter of about 3.39 inches and a boot height of 3.9 inches, so measure the hoof and match the stated size.

Are these bell boots waterproof?

The Harrison Howard rubber is stated as waterproof. The other makers do not state waterproofing, so check the material each maker lists.

Can bell boots be used for training and competition?

The maker lists the Abbylike boots as suited to competition and training, and the Professional’s Choice boots as suited to training or competition. The Harrison Howard pair states no use.

More from the barn

See every horse hoof boot guide and all hoof boots vs horseshoes guides.

More picks: best horse hoof pick, hoof pick vs hoof rasp, hoof pick vs hoof knife and hand vs electric hoof trimmers.