
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Olicity Grade 100 unbleached cheesecloth9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
Nut Milk BagsView on Amazon - 3
3 PCS Reusable Cheesecloth Bag & Nut Milk BagsView on Amazon - 4
3 Pcs 14"x14" Nut Milk BagView on Amazon - 5
3 Pcs 12"x12" Nut Milk BagView on Amazon - 6
Country Trading Co. Organic CheeseclothView on Amazon - 7
10 PCS CheeseclothView on Amazon
Morning milking is done, the pail is full, and now you need the milk clean and the cheese started, which is where cheesecloth vs nut milk bag comes in. The short answer: a nut milk bag is a sewn cloth bag with a fine mesh and usually a drawstring, made for repeated straining of milk, yogurt, cheese and nut milk. Cheesecloth is a woven cotton cloth, traditionally sold by grade and cut to size, better for lining molds, covering curds and one-off jobs. Buy the bag for straining you do every week; keep cheesecloth for wrapping, covering and lining.
Also worth comparing
Nut Milk BagsCheck price on Amazon
3 PCS Reusable Cheesecloth Bag & Nut Milk BagsCheck price on Amazon
3 Pcs 14"x14" Nut Milk BagCheck price on Amazon
3 Pcs 12"x12" Nut Milk BagCheck price on Amazon
Country Trading Co. Organic CheeseclothCheck price on Amazon
10 PCS CheeseclothCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Cheesecloth vs nut milk bag: the short answer
Both strain, but they are built differently. A nut milk bag is sewn into a bag with a drawstring closure and a U-shaped or round bottom, so you pour in the liquid, pull the string and squeeze. Cheesecloth is a flat woven cloth you drape over a bowl, line a mold with or fold into layers for finer filtering. The listings we compared sell both forms, and several sell cheesecloth sewn into bag shapes too, which blurs the line. Pick by job: repeated liquid straining favors the bag, and lining, covering and wrapping favor the flat cloth. For cloth picks, see our best cheesecloth for straining yogurt comparison.
Two forms compared
| Form | Example listings | Stated sizes | Stated weave or mesh |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nut milk bag | SCENGCLOS 2-pack, Fancymay 3-pack, Huppar 6-pack | 12 x 12 in, 16 x 16 in | Weave 66 x 70 (SCENGCLOS), 0.2 mm mesh |
| Cheesecloth bag | New England Stories 3-pack, MOWPOG 3-pack, AUXIN 4-pack | 14 x 14 in, 4 x 6 in (AUXIN) | Grade 100 (New England Stories, MOWPOG), 0.15 mm (MOWPOG) |
| Strainer set with frame | Esuduky 5-piece | 6.69 x 5.12 x 0.43 in | 0.01 in mesh, cotton cloths plus a nylon bag |
Our pick for each job
- Bag for weekly straining: the MOWPOG 3-pack. The listing states a U-shaped bottom, a drawstring, grade 100 mesh and a 0.15 mm mesh opening, all in 14 x 14 inch cotton.
- Cloth for lining and wrapping: the New England Stories 3-pack. The listing states grade 100 unbleached cotton, precut 14 x 14 inch pieces with sewn edges, so nothing needs cutting.
Weave and fineness
Weave decides what stays behind. The SCENGCLOS bag lists a 66 x 70 weave with a 0.2 mm mesh opening, and its listing states this is tighter than cheesecloth grade 90, which gives you a useful reference point. The New England Stories and MOWPOG bags list grade 100, a finer grade, with MOWPOG also listing a 0.15 mm mesh opening. The Pardal Store bag lists a 0.5 mm mesh opening, the coarsest figure in our listings. For goat milk straining, yogurt and soft cheese, the finer listings catch more sediment in one pass; the AUXIN listing claims fine filtration without repeated passes. When a listing gives no grade or mesh figure, as several here do not, assume a standard weave and plan to fold the cloth or strain twice.
Shape and handling
Bags win on handling. The Fancymay, Huppar and MOWPOG bags list a U-shaped bottom that keeps pulp out of the corners while you squeeze, with a drawstring to close the top. The New England Stories bag lists a drawstring too and notes it can hang hands-free from a container, pitcher or blender carafe. Outward seams, listed by SCENGCLOS and Fancymay, make the bag easier to turn and rinse. The AUXIN set takes the opposite approach: four small 4 x 6 inch bags for single servings of cold brew, tea or juice. The Esuduky set adds a rust-resistant stainless steel frame with a dual-hook handle and a zipper, a different answer for cooks who strain at the counter every day.
Cleaning and reuse
Every listing here sells the bag or cloth as reusable, and most call it washable. A simple routine that fits what the listings say:
- Turn the bag inside out and rinse it under running water right after use, as the Cotton Farm listing describes.
- Wash with warm soapy water, as the Fancymay and Huppar listings say, or a tiny drop of dish soap, as the Pardal Store listing says.
- Rinse the soap out and let it air dry completely before storage.
- For cloth that strained milk, you may want to sanitize it. The AUXIN listing states its bags can be boiled in water and are not for the oven or microwave. Check the maker’s line before boiling any other brand.
- Wash new AUXIN bags before first use, as that listing advises.
The Esuduky filters are detachable, and the listing states they can be hand washed or machine washed.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers straining cloth and bags only. It does not cover how to pasteurize milk, how long to age cheese or any animal health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about milk handling and goat health. For the next step after straining, see cheese press vs cheese mold and the best cheese making kit for gift ideas.
Cotton or nylon: what the listings say
Most of the products here are cotton. SCENGCLOS, AUXIN, Fancymay, New England Stories, The Pardal Store, Huppar, Cotton Farm and MOWPOG all describe 100% cotton, mostly unbleached. Esuduky is mixed: its set holds 3 cotton cheese cloths and 1 nylon bag, with the cotton for fine filtering and the nylon for coarse tasks such as soups and sauces. Fancymay is a cotton bag with triple stitching and a drawstring. The SCENGCLOS title calls its product both nut milk bags and cheesecloth bags, which is marketing, not a grade claim. Sizes are usually given as flat bag dimensions, such as 12 x 12 or 16 x 16 inches, not as working volume.
FAQs from goat keepers
Can I strain goat milk with a nut milk bag?
Yes. A fine-mesh cotton bag such as the grade 100 bags from New England Stories or MOWPOG strains milk, and the drawstring lets you hang it while it drains.
Which is finer, grade 90 or grade 100 cheesecloth?
Grade 100 is finer. The SCENGCLOS listing describes its 66 x 70 weave as tighter than grade 90, and the New England Stories and MOWPOG listings both state grade 100.
Are nut milk bags washable and reusable?
The listings say yes across the board. Rinse after use, wash with warm soapy water, and air dry completely before storing, as the Fancymay, Huppar and Pardal Store listings describe.
Should I buy a drawstring bag or a flat cloth?
Choose the drawstring bag for straining liquids you make often, such as milk, yogurt or nut milk. Choose flat cheesecloth for lining cheese molds, covering curds and wrapping, and compare cloth options with muslin vs cheesecloth.
More from the barn
See every milk pail and strainer guide and all milking guides. Also see our best cheesecloth for straining yogurt. Also see our muslin vs cheesecloth.
More picks: browse cheese press vs cheese mold, cheese making kits for gifts and milking.
