Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Stainless Steel vs Plastic Milk Pail: Which One Should You Buy?

Stainless steel vs plastic milk pail, compared on a steel can, a steel pail and plastic pails: capacity, lid, pour spout, weight and which keeper each suits.

Top picks

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

How we score

Stainless Steel vs Plastic Milk Pail: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1ProSelect Stainless Steel PailProSelect Stainless Steel Pail9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Winco Plastic Pail 14 qt GrayWinco Plastic Pail 14 qt Gray9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Winco Plastic Pail 10 qt RedWinco Plastic Pail 10 qt Red9.5/10View on Amazon
  4. 4GOVNPJ Stainless Milk Can 1 GalGOVNPJ Stainless Milk Can 1 Gal9.5/10View on Amazon

The stainless steel vs plastic milk pail question comes up as soon as the morning milking leaves a pail to carry, wash and store. Both kinds hold milk; the difference is whether the pail resists rust and dents, as the steel examples show, or pours cleanly and weighs little, as the plastic examples show. We compared pails on capacity, lid and pour spout, weight, stated safety features and warranty, using only what each listing publishes.

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Quick verdict: choose the stainless steel side if the pail will hang on a fence and stand up to daily use, as the ProSelect example shows with its snag-free contoured handles and life time warranty. Choose the plastic side if the pail must pour without drips and weigh little in the hand, as the Winco examples show with their angled pour spouts and graduation markings. The sides also sit in different capacity classes, so read this as a comparison of materials, not of models.

The examples

ProSelect Stainless Steel Pail

ProSelect Stainless Steel Pail

Pro Select9.6/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A heavy duty stainless steel pail in 9-Quart with contoured snag-free handles and a life time warranty.

Pros

  • Will not crack, rust, or break
  • Contoured handles with a snag-free design for added safety
  • Hangs on fences, cages, crates or kennels
  • Life time warranty is stated

Cons

  • No lid is stated, so milk stays open in the pail
  • No pour spout is stated
  • No graduation markings are stated
  • Black and gray is the only color stated
Winco Plastic Pail 14 qt Gray

Winco Plastic Pail 14 qt Gray

Winco9.6/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A gray 14 quart heavy-duty plastic pail with a pour spout, graduation markings and a BPA-free build.

Pros

  • Angled pour spout allows drip free pouring
  • Molded-in graduation markings in pints and quarts
  • Dishwasher safe and BPA-free
  • Easy-lift bail with rotating hand grip for comfortable pouring

Cons

  • No warranty term is stated
  • No lid is stated, so milk stays open in the pail
  • Gray is the only color stated
  • 1.52 pounds, heavier than the 10 quart Winco pail
Winco Plastic Pail 10 qt Red

Winco Plastic Pail 10 qt Red

Winco9.5/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A red 10 quart heavy-duty plastic pail with a pour spout, graduation markings and a BPA-free build.

Pros

  • Angled pour spout allows drip free pouring
  • Molded-in graduation markings in pints and quarts
  • Dishwasher safe and BPA-free
  • 1.17 pounds, lighter than the 14 quart Winco pail

Cons

  • No warranty term is stated
  • No lid is stated, so milk stays open in the pail
  • Red is the only color stated
  • 10 quart capacity suits a smaller milking than the 14 quart pail
GOVNPJ Stainless Milk Can 1 Gal

GOVNPJ Stainless Milk Can 1 Gal

GOVNPJ9.5/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A gray 1 gallon stainless steel milk can with a sealed lid, clasps and carry handles for transport.

Pros

  • Sealed lid with clasps and integrated carry handles
  • Rust and pitting resistant stainless steel
  • Usable capacity of 3.5L for milk, water, tea or wine
  • Stands up to daily use with a long service life

Cons

  • Gray is the only color stated
  • No pour spout is stated
  • No graduation markings are stated
  • 1 gallon capacity is smaller than the 9-quart and 14 quart pails here

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


Also worth comparing

Stainless steel vs plastic milk pail: side by side

Pail GoatGear Score Material Capacity Lid / Pour Warranty Amazon
ProSelect Stainless Steel Pail 9.6/10 Stainless steel 9-Quart Not stated Life time View on Amazon
Winco Plastic Pail 14 qt Gray 9.6/10 Plastic 14 qt Pour spout Not stated View on Amazon
Winco Plastic Pail 10 qt Red 9.5/10 Plastic 10 qt Pour spout Not stated View on Amazon
GOVNPJ Stainless Milk Can 1 Gal 9.5/10 Stainless steel 1 Gallon Sealed lid Not stated View on Amazon

These are maker ratings taken from the goat gear listings on 14 November 2026, not our own measurements.

How each one holds and pours milk

A steel pail is built to hang and to last. The ProSelect pail hangs on fences, cages, crates or kennels by contoured handles with a snag-free design, and the maker states it will not crack, rust, or break. The GOVNPJ can adds a sealed lid with clasps and integrated carry handles, so milk stays inside while the can moves. Neither steel example states a pour spout, so pouring means tipping the pail by hand.

A plastic pail is built to pour. Both Winco pails have an angled pour spout for drip free pouring and an easy-lift bail with a rotating hand grip for comfortable pouring at any angle. Molded-in graduation markings in pints and quarts let the keeper gauge capacity without a measuring jug. For more steel options, see our best stainless steel milk pail picks.

Capacity and size

Capacity runs from 1 Gallon on the GOVNPJ can to 14 quart on the gray Winco pail. The GOVNPJ can lists an outer shell total volume of 5L and a practical usable capacity of 3.5L, called 1 Gallon in the title; the usable figure is the one to plan around. The ProSelect pail is 9-Quart and also comes in 1-, 2-, 4-, 6-, and 13-quart sizes. It measures 11.5 by 9.8 by 9.0 inches.

The plastic pails state their weight: the red 10 quart Winco weighs 1.17 pounds and measures 11.81 by 11.54 by 10.24 inches, while the gray 14 quart Winco weighs 1.52 pounds and measures 13.19 by 12.99 by 10.83 inches. The GOVNPJ can states no weight, and the ProSelect weight line reads 0.000625 pounds, which cannot describe a steel pail, so neither steel example gives a usable weight. For size questions, see our small vs large milk pail comparison.

Cleaning and daily use

Cleaning is where the plastic side is clearest. Both Winco pails are dishwasher safe and BPA-free, with commercial-grade plastic built for daily use in janitorial and foodservice environments. The steel examples state no dishwasher claim: the GOVNPJ can relies on a sealed lid and stainless steel that resists rust and pitting, while the ProSelect pail relies on steel that will not crack, rust, or break.

Warranty is the sharpest split. The ProSelect pail states a life time warranty, while the GOVNPJ can and both Winco pails state no warranty term at all. The gaps go further: the GOVNPJ can gives two capacity figures, the ProSelect gives no usable weight, and neither plastic pail states a lid. If any of those points decides your purchase, ask the seller before you order.

Which should you choose?

Choose a stainless steel milk pail if the pail will hang on a fence, take daily knocks and stand up to daily use, as the ProSelect example shows with its snag-free contoured handles and life time warranty. The GOVNPJ can suits a keeper who carries milk and wants a sealed lid with clasps. Keepers who strain milk after milking can also compare our best milk strainer for goat milk picks.

Choose a plastic milk pail if the pail must pour without drips, show its level at a glance and wash in the dishwasher, as the Winco examples show with their angled pour spouts, graduation markings and BPA-free plastic. Pick the 10 quart pail for a lighter carry and the 14 quart pail for a larger milking.

Whichever you pick, check the capacity figure the listing gives for the size you order, since the GOVNPJ can shows how two figures can sit in one listing.

Around the Barn

  • Hang the ProSelect pail on the fence by its contoured handles between milkings.
  • Close the sealed lid with clasps before carrying the steel can.
  • Use the graduation markings to gauge capacity in pints and quarts.
  • Wash the dishwasher safe pails in the dishwasher after milking.

FAQs from goat keepers

Is a stainless steel or plastic milk pail better for goats?

It depends on the job. Steel resists rust and dents and hangs on a fence, as the ProSelect example shows with a life time warranty. Plastic pours without drips, shows its level and washes in the dishwasher, as the Winco examples show with BPA-free plastic.

How much milk does a milk pail hold?

Capacities here run from 1 Gallon on the GOVNPJ can to 14 quart on the gray Winco pail, with the ProSelect at 9-Quart and the red Winco at 10 quart. The GOVNPJ can lists a usable capacity of 3.5L inside a 5L outer shell.

Are plastic milk pails BPA-free?

The Winco pails in this comparison state BPA-free plastic and dishwasher safe construction. The steel examples state no BPA claim, since the claim applies to plastic.

Do milk pails come with a lid?

Only the GOVNPJ can states a lid, a sealed lid with clasps. The ProSelect pail and both Winco pails state no lid in their listings, so check before ordering if a lid matters.

ProSelect Stainless Steel Pail
Still deciding? Our top pickProSelect Stainless Steel Pail
Check price on Amazon

Behind the Farm Score

Product GoatGear Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
ProSelect Stainless Steel Pail 9.6 30 22 21 5 0
Winco Plastic Pail 14 qt Gray 9.6 29 21 21 5 0
Winco Plastic Pail 10 qt Red 9.5 28 21 20 5 0
GOVNPJ Stainless Milk Can 1 Gal 9.5 27 20 20 5 0

A score of 9.2 marks the weakest point total on our scale and 9.8 the strongest; totals in between are placed proportionally.

The GoatGear Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For milk pails, safety points need a stated safety feature such as BPA-free plastic, a snag-free handle or rust resistance. The ProSelect leads on its life time warranty and snag-free handles, while the Winco pails earn safety points for BPA-free plastic and dishwasher safe construction. Only the ProSelect states a warranty term, so the rest score zero on warranty. How we pick explains the weights.

More from the barn

See every milk pails and strainers guide and all goat milking guides.

More picks: stainless steel milk pails, milk can vs milk pail, flat sided vs round milk pail and how to clean milking equipment.