Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Digital vs Analog Electric Fence Tester: Which One Should You Buy?

Digital vs analog electric fence tester: LCD digits or neon glow lamps. Ranges, precision, batteries and which type suits your goat fence.

Digital vs Analog Electric Fence Tester: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1SolKang Electric Fence TesterSolKang Electric Fence Tester9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Gallagher Digital Electric Fence Tester Digital Fence TesterGallagher Digital Electric Fence Tester Digital Fence TesterView on Amazon
  3. 3AstroAI Digital Multimeter Tester 2000 Counts with DC ACAstroAI Digital Multimeter Tester 2000 Counts with DC ACView on Amazon

A digital fence tester shows the voltage as a number on a screen; an analog tester shows it as glowing neon lamps. That is the core of digital vs analog electric fence tester: digits you read exactly versus lamps you read by brightness and count. Digital suits anyone who wants a precise number, analog suits anyone who wants a tool with no batteries that always works. For most goat keepers, either gets the job done.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Digital vs analog electric fence tester: the short answer

Choose digital if you want exact readings: the listings here show ranges like 300V to 9.9kV on the allsun digital and 0 to 12,000 volts on the Gallagher digital, with three-digit readouts like the Zareba’s 0.5 to 19.9kV. Choose analog (neon) if you want simplicity: the ALLOSUN neon reads 0.6kV to 7kV and the L-FENCE reads 2kV to 12kV with 8 neon lamps, and neither needs batteries. Digital costs more and needs batteries; neon is simpler and always ready.

What a digital fence tester does

A digital tester measures the fence pulse and shows the voltage as digits on an LCD. The allsun digital reads 300V to 9.9kV and displays in kV, so 6.0 on the screen means 6.0kV. The Gallagher digital measures 0 to 12,000 volts with 100V precision under 10kV and 1,000V steps above. The Zareba DEFT gives a three-digit readout from 0.5 to 19.9kV with a backlit display for day and night. The FenceMate reads up to 15,000 volts with a large LCD and automatic on/off. The ANDMON reads 0 to 13kV and can also check battery voltage from 0 to 19.9V.

Digital testers need power. The Gallagher runs on a 9V battery with a 6 to 12 month lifespan; the FenceMate includes a 9V battery; the Zareba and ANDMON need a 9V battery not included; the briidea takes 4 AA batteries not included. Most switch themselves off: the allsun digital shuts down after 4 seconds of inactivity, and the ANDMON does the same. The Gallagher turns on automatically when connected, and the M MINGYA shows volts, amps and current direction with a backlit screen.

What an analog (neon) fence tester does

An analog tester uses neon glow lamps instead of a screen. You hook it to the wire, stick the probe in the ground, and the lamps glow: the higher the voltage, the brighter the glow, and on multi-lamp models like the L-FENCE with its 8 neon indicator lights, more lamps lit means higher voltage. The ALLOSUN neon reads 0.6kV to 7kV (600 to 7,000 volts); the L-FENCE reads 2kV to 12kV.

Neon testers need no batteries: they run on the fence voltage itself, which excites the neon bulbs. That means nothing to charge, no batteries to buy, and nothing to go flat in the truck. The trade-off is precision: you read brightness and lamp count, not digits. And the ALLOSUN listing warns the neon will not show well in direct sunlight; shade it with your hand to read it. It is rated for 0 to 40 degrees C operating temperature.

Reading the numbers: ranges and precision

Voltage ranges vary widely. Neon: 0.6 to 7kV on the ALLOSUN and 2 to 12kV on the L-FENCE. Digital: 300V to 9.9kV on the allsun, 0 to 12,000V on the Gallagher, 0.5 to 19.9kV on the Zareba, up to 15,000V on the FenceMate, 0 to 13kV on the ANDMON, 300V to 15,000V on the briidea, and 0.2 to 15kV on the M MINGYA. Match the range to your energizer: a tester that tops out below your charger’s output cannot show you the full reading.

Precision is where digital wins clearly. The Gallagher’s 100V steps under 10kV let you see small changes as you walk the line; a neon lamp’s brightness steps are coarser. If you track down faults by watching the voltage fall, finer steps make the drop easier to spot.

Batteries, weight and size

Neon testers are light and battery-free: the ALLOSUN is 5 x 2 x 1 inches at 0.1 kg, and the L-FENCE is 6.7 x 2.8 x 0.8 inches at 0.07 kg. Digital testers are heavier: the Gallagher digital is 3 x 5 x 9 inches at 4.8 ounces, the allsun digital is 6.85 x 2.76 x 1.3 inches at 228 grams, the ANDMON is 6.2 ounces, the briidea is 4 x 5 x 2 inches at 0.95 ounces, and the M MINGYA is 0.22 kg. If the tester lives in your pocket, weight matters, and so does remembering to keep spare batteries.

Which one should you buy

Buy digital if you want exact numbers, walk long fences, or track small voltage changes. The Gallagher SmartFix goes further with voltage and current readings plus directional arrows, for keepers who want fault-finding as well as voltage. Buy neon if you want the simplest tool that never needs batteries and you are comfortable reading lamps. Many keepers end up with both: a neon tester in the truck as a backup and a digital on the belt for serious fault hunting. Either way, check that the voltage range covers your energizer’s output.

Type Display Example range Batteries Best for
Digital LCD digits 300V-9.9kV (allsun); 0-12,000V (Gallagher) 9V or AA needed Precise readings
Analog (neon) Glow lamps 0.6-7kV (ALLOSUN); 2-12kV (L-FENCE) None Simplicity, backup

FAQs from goat keepers

Do neon fence testers work in sunlight?

Not well in direct sunlight. The ALLOSUN listing says to shade the lamps with your hand; they will not be bright, but they are visible.

What batteries do digital fence testers need?

Most use a 9V battery: the Gallagher, FenceMate, Zareba, ANDMON and M MINGYA. The briidea uses 4 AA batteries. Some include the battery and some do not, so check the listing.

How precise are digital readings?

The Gallagher digital reads in 100V steps under 10kV, and the Zareba gives a three-digit readout from 0.5 to 19.9kV. Neon testers read by lamp brightness, which is coarser.

Which testers show current direction?

The Gallagher SmartFix measures voltage and current with directional arrows, and the M MINGYA shows volts, amps and direction. Standard digital testers show voltage only.

Do any of these have a warranty?

The ALLOSUN neon states 12 months, the allsun digital states 1 year, the ANDMON states a 1-year warranty, and the Gallagher SmartFix states 1 year.

More from the barn

See every fence tester guide and all fencing and shelter guides.

More picks: fence testers for troubleshooting and fence testers for livestock containment.