Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Grain Feeder vs Feed Pan: Which One Should You Buy?

Grain feeder vs feed pan: a wall feeder, fence troughs, a grain gate and a plain pan compared on capacity, mounting, materials and cleaning.

Grain Feeder vs Feed Pan: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1VEVOR Livestock Hay FeederVEVOR Livestock Hay Feeder9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Sadnyy 8 Quart Rubber Feed PanSadnyy 8 Quart Rubber Feed Pan9.7/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Little Giant® Plastic Utility PanLittle Giant® Plastic Utility PanView on Amazon
  4. 4Fortiflex Mini Feed Pan for Dogs and HorsesFortiflex Mini Feed Pan for Dogs and HorsesView on Amazon
  5. 5Goat Hay FeederGoat Hay FeederView on Amazon
  6. 6Pasture Hay Feeder 45 Gallon for Farms Hay Grain LivestockPasture Hay Feeder 45 Gallon for Farms Hay Grain LivestockView on Amazon
  7. 74 Pack Rubber Feed Pan4 Pack Rubber Feed PanView on Amazon
  8. 86Pcs Rubber Feed Pan6Pcs Rubber Feed PanView on Amazon

Morning grain time in the goat pen sorts itself into camps fast: the goats that crowd a wall feeder and the goats that eat better from a pan on the ground, and grain feeder vs feed pan is the choice that decides which camp eats calmly. This guide compares a wall-mounted grain feeder, a set of fence troughs, a grain gate and a plain feed pan side by side, using only what the listings state about capacity, mounting, materials and cleaning, and it names the gaps where a listing says little or nothing.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Grain feeder vs feed pan: the short answer

A wall-mounted grain feeder suits a barn or shed with a solid wall and goats that eat together at one spot, because it stays off the floor and the tray catches what spills. A feed pan suits a pen with no wall to mount on, a goat that needs its own ration away from the group, or grain served apart from hay. A grain gate also appears below, but it moves grain out of storage rather than serving it, so read it as storage hardware, not as a feeder. If you want pans only, our best feed pan roundup compares pans for goats.

The four listings, ranked

The gear section below ranks the four listings from the strongest fit for this topic to the weakest, using the GoatGear Score weights: performance, build, value, safety and warranty. The two listings that serve grain to goats lead, the grain gate follows because it dispenses grain from storage and never serves it, and the title-only pan closes the list because its listing states almost nothing beyond size and material.

Listing Type Stated capacity Mounting
Meyoppm 2 in 1 Wall Mount Hay and Grain Feeder Wall feeder with grain tray 25 gallons Wall mount, kit included
NZJWZS 3-Pack Metal Feed Troughs Fence troughs 6 qt each, 18 quarts total Carabiners, zip ties or screws
TRUCFUSION Sliding Grain Gate with Chute Grain gate for IBC tote Not stated IBC tote or grain bin
Little Giant Plastic Utility Pan Feed pan 5 quart Floor, no hardware stated

Meyoppm 2 in 1 Wall Mount Hay and Grain Feeder

The Meyoppm listing pairs a hay rack with a grain tray in one wall-mounted unit, the closest match to this topic, with hay above, grain below, and a tray that catches spilled hay and mineral feed pellets. It lists 25 gallons, galvanized steel, a reinforced frame with finished edges and a mounting kit with clear alignment marks. The spec table gives 21.59 x 11.78 x 21.59 inches in black. The listing says the feeder can be rinsed or cleaned thoroughly as it hangs, with no disassembly. No warranty term is stated.

NZJWZS 3-Pack Metal Feed Troughs

The NZJWZS listing ships as a 3-pack of coated metal troughs, each holding 6 qt, for 18 quarts of total feeding space. The open shape makes refilling and checking feed levels simple, and the listing names grain, pellets, minerals and grit as the dry feed it holds. Four drain holes with plugs release rinse water during cleaning, and the plugs go back in when the troughs hold dry feed outdoors. Mounting covers fences, panels, coops and walls: carabiners, zip ties and screws come in the box, and the listing says to use screws or reinforced ties for active goats or piglets. Smooth rolled edges and a rust-resistant coating round out the listing. No warranty term is stated.

TRUCFUSION Sliding Grain Gate with Chute

The TRUCFUSION listing is grain-handling hardware, not a feeder: a sliding gate with a discharge chute that fits an IBC tote, grain bin, hopper or conveyor, and meters grain out by gravity. It lists alloy steel with an orange powder coat, stainless steel hardware and a 9 x 9 inch sliding panel. The spec table gives 13.4 x 5.9 x 9.9 inches. The chute guides feed into a container and the sliding track controls flow with little effort, so the gate suits moving grain from storage to a bucket or feeder. No warranty term is stated.

Little Giant Plastic Utility Pan

The Little Giant listing states the least: a plastic utility pan in green, sized at 5 quart, sold as a feed pan. No bullets and no spec table accompany the title, so mounting and cleaning are not stated. It closes the ranking because a title alone gives a buyer little to compare.

Reading capacity: gallons, quarts and pan size

Capacity on these listings comes in gallons and quarts, and makers measure it differently, so compare within one unit and never across them. The Meyoppm feeder lists 25 gallons. The NZJWZS troughs list 6 qt each and 18 quarts across the 3-pack. The Little Giant pan lists 5 quart. The TRUCFUSION gate lists no capacity, because it moves grain rather than holding it. None of these listings converts its capacity into a weight of grain or a daily ration, so treat the stated figures as a way to rank containers, not as a feeding plan.

Mounting and where the feeder goes

Mounting decides how steady the feeder is and how easy it is to fill. The Meyoppm feeder mounts on a wall, guardrail or shed frame with the included mounting kit, with clear alignment marks. The NZJWZS troughs hang from fences, panels, coops or walls with carabiners, zip ties or screws, and the listing says to use screws or reinforced ties for active goats or piglets. The Little Giant pan sits on the floor with no hardware, which suits a pen with no wall at all. The TRUCFUSION gate mounts to storage, an IBC tote or a grain bin, and the listing advises cutting the discharge opening slightly smaller than 9 x 9 inches. Place grain feeders away from water buckets so spilled grain stays dry, and keep a separate goat mineral feeder nearby rather than mixing minerals into the grain feeder.

Materials: galvanized steel, coated metal, alloy steel or plastic

Material sets how long a feeder lasts in a damp barn or outdoor pen. The listings we compared use four materials:

  • Galvanized steel: the Meyoppm feeder, with a reinforced frame and finished edges.
  • Coated metal: the NZJWZS troughs, with a rust-resistant coating and smooth rolled edges.
  • Alloy steel with orange powder coat: the TRUCFUSION gate, with stainless steel hardware.
  • Plastic: the Little Giant pan, in green.

Steel feeders hold up to chewing and climbing better than plastic, and galvanized and powder-coated finishes suit feeders that live outdoors or in a damp barn. A plastic pan trades sturdiness for light weight and easy moving.

Grain trays and 2-in-1 designs

Some feeders add a tray under the rack. The Meyoppm feeder pairs its hay rack with a grain tray, and the tray catches spilled hay and mineral feed pellets so less feed ends up in the bedding. The NZJWZS troughs are open trays with no rack above, and the open shape makes it easy to see when grain runs low. The Little Giant pan is a single open pan with no rack and no tray. A tray also means another surface to rinse, though the Meyoppm feeder cleans without disassembly. If you feed grain at a separate time and place from hay, a plain pan without a rack is simpler to carry and clean.

Read the listing twice

Feeder listings often contradict themselves, and the conflicting numbers are usually the ones you need to plan the install:

  • TRUCFUSION: the title and bullets say 9 x 9 inches for the sliding panel, while the product image shows 7.68 x 7.29 inches. The listing itself calls the image figure a reference value based on manual measurement, and advises cutting the discharge opening slightly smaller than 9 x 9 inches. Plan the cut around the 9 x 9 figure and measure the gate on arrival.
  • Little Giant: the listing is a title only, with no bullets and no spec table. Size, 5 quart, material, plastic, and color, green, are all it states.
  • Meyoppm: the title lists 25 gallons while the spec table gives dimensions only, 21.59 x 11.78 x 21.59 inches, with 21.59 inches appearing twice and no capacity figure to cross-check.
  • NZJWZS: the pack math is consistent, 6 qt per trough across 3 troughs for 18 quarts total, and the four drain holes match the title. The listing gives no weight per trough, so hanging strength rests on the screws or ties you choose.

Measure your wall or pen before ordering and allow for the larger figure. Some listings also make feeding claims we leave out, because a feeder is equipment, not a health product.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers feeder hardware only. It does not cover how much grain a goat needs, grain types or any health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about rations and goat health.

FAQs from goat keepers

Is a grain feeder or a feed pan better for goats?

It depends on your setup. A wall-mounted grain feeder such as the 25 gallon Meyoppm suits a barn with a solid wall, a feed pan such as the 5 quart Little Giant suits a pen with no wall or a goat that eats apart from the group, and the NZJWZS 3-pack suits several animals eating at once.

Can a feed pan hold grain and minerals?

A pan can hold dry feed: the NZJWZS troughs list grain, pellets, minerals and grit, while the Meyoppm tray catches mineral feed pellets that spill from the rack above. Keep minerals in their own feeder when you can, and use the pan for grain at feeding time.

How many troughs come in the NZJWZS set?

The set ships as a 3-pack, with 6 qt in each trough and 18 quarts across the set, and four drain holes with plugs release rinse water during cleaning.

Does a grain gate replace a grain feeder?

No. The TRUCFUSION gate meters grain out of an IBC tote, grain bin or hopper through a 9 x 9 inch sliding panel, and it serves storage, not goats. Pair it with a feeder or pan that holds the grain once it leaves storage.

Do these feeders come with mounting hardware?

Some do. The Meyoppm feeder includes a mounting kit with alignment marks, the NZJWZS troughs include carabiners, zip ties and screws, and the Little Giant pan lists no hardware, since a pan sits on the floor.

More from the barn

See every feed pan guide and all feeding and water guides.

More picks: best hay feeders for goats, goat mineral feeders, heated water buckets and goat shelters.