Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Hay Bag vs Hay Net: Which One Should You Buy?

Hay bag vs hay net, compared on 2 Derby Originals slow feeder hay bags and 1 Tough 1 nylon tote: feed openings, hay capacity, weight, materials and which keeper each suits.

Top picks

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

How we score

Hay Bag vs Hay Net: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Derby Slow Feeder BlackDerby Slow Feeder Black9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Derby Slow Feeder Hunter GreenDerby Slow Feeder Hunter Green9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Tough 1 Nylon Hay ToteTough 1 Nylon Hay Tote9.6/10View on Amazon

Morning chores always end the same way: a pile of good hay trampled into the bedding while the goats stand on it and wait for more. The hay bag vs hay net question is really about how to slow that down and keep hay off the ground. We compared the Derby Originals slow feeder hay bags against the Tough 1 nylon tote with a net front, on openings, capacity, weight, materials and the warranty each maker states.

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Quick verdict: choose the hay bag side if you want small, stated feed openings and a defined flake capacity, as both Derby Originals examples show with 1.75 inch square openings, 2-3 flakes of hay and a 6-month limited warranty. Choose the hay net side if you want one extra-large tote with a net front and the lowest stated weight, as the Tough 1 example shows at 1.5 pounds with 2 by 2 inch poly rope openings and a 90-day coverage term. Read on for what separates the two sides and where each listing leaves questions.

Three examples

Derby Slow Feeder Black

Derby Slow Feeder Black

Derby Originals9.7/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A heavy-duty reinforced nylon hay bag with 1.75 inch square feed openings, a 2-3 flake capacity and a 6-month limited manufacturer's warranty.

Pros

  • 1.75 inch square feed openings sized for slow feeding
  • Holds 2-3 flakes of hay, including Timothy, Orchard or Alfalfa
  • Super Tough Bottom of reinforced overlapping nylon webbing lets dust and debris exit
  • Replaceable hanging straps and snaps, so worn parts can be swapped

Cons

  • 6-month warranty covers manufacturing defects only, not accidental damage or normal wear
  • No depth or hanging measurements are stated
  • Written for horse hay feeding; the listing does not name goats
Derby Slow Feeder Hunter Green

Derby Slow Feeder Hunter Green

Derby Originals9.6/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

The same Front Web Slow Feeder hay bag listing in hunter green, with 1.75 inch square openings, a 2-3 flake capacity and the same 6-month limited warranty.

Pros

  • 1.75 inch square feed openings sized for slow feeding
  • Holds 2-3 flakes of hay, including Timothy, Orchard or Alfalfa
  • Super Tough Bottom of reinforced overlapping nylon webbing lets dust and debris exit
  • Replaceable hanging straps and snaps, so worn parts can be swapped

Cons

  • Near-identical listing to the black bag; the only stated difference is the color
  • No item weight is stated
  • 6-month warranty covers manufacturing defects only, not accidental damage or normal wear
  • Written for horse hay feeding; the listing does not name goats
Tough 1 Nylon Hay Tote

Tough 1 Nylon Hay Tote

Tough 19.6/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

An extra-large heavyweight nylon hay tote with a poly rope net front of 2 by 2 inch openings, an adjustable hanging strap and 90-day coverage from JT International.

Pros

  • Poly rope net front with 2 by 2 inch openings
  • Extra-large size the maker describes as easy to load
  • Heavyweight nylon body with a stated weight of 1.5 pounds
  • Adjustable strap with clip for hanging, plus a snap closure

Cons

  • Stated as not water resistant
  • Hand wash only care instructions
  • 90-day coverage term is shorter than the Derby 6-month warranty term

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


Also worth comparing

Hay bag vs hay net: side by side

Feeder GoatGear Score Side Feed openings Hay capacity Weight Warranty Amazon
Derby Slow Feeder Black 9.7/10 Hay bag 1.75 inch square 2-3 flakes of hay 2.5 pounds 6-month limited warranty View on Amazon
Derby Slow Feeder Hunter Green 9.6/10 Hay bag 1.75 inch square 2-3 flakes of hay Not stated 6-month limited warranty View on Amazon
Tough 1 Nylon Hay Tote 9.6/10 Hay net front 2 by 2 inch poly rope Not stated 1.5 pounds 90-day coverage View on Amazon

Sizes and capacities are the manufacturer’s numbers as each listing states them, pulled 23 October 2026.

How each side feeds

A hay bag is a closed bag with the feed openings worked into the webbing. The Derby listings are front-web slow feeders: the goat pulls hay through 1.75 inch square openings in the front web, which paces intake one mouthful at a time. The hay net side here is a hybrid rather than a plain net: the Tough 1 is a nylon tote body with a poly rope net front of 2 by 2 inch openings, so the feeding face works like a net while the tote holds its shape for loading. Both sides slow feeding by making the goat work for each pull; the bag states smaller openings than the tote’s net front.

On loading, the Derby bullets state a 2-3 flake capacity and an easy loading design, with a Super Tough Bottom that lets dust and debris exit the bag. The Tough 1 bullets call the tote extra-large and easy to load, with a snap closure and an adjustable strap with clip for hanging. For more net options sized for small herds, see our hay nets for four goats picks.

Openings, capacity and weight

Feed openings are the clearest stated difference. Both Derby bags state 1.75 inch square openings in the front web. The Tough 1 net front states 2 by 2 inch poly rope openings, a wider mouth per pull. Capacity is stated only on the bag side: both Derby listings state 2-3 flakes of hay, while the Tough 1 states no flake count or volume, only extra-large sizing and 29 by 21 by 7 inch dimensions. One side cannot be called better on capacity when only one side states a figure.

Weight is stated on two of the three listings: the black Derby bag at 2.5 pounds and the Tough 1 tote at 1.5 pounds. The hunter green Derby listing states no item weight. So the tote is the lowest stated weight, but that comparison only covers the two listings that give a number.

Straps, materials and care

The Derby bags are heavy-duty reinforced nylon with a Super Tough Bottom of overlapping nylon webbing, and the hanging straps and snaps are replaceable, so worn parts can be swapped instead of retiring the bag. The Tough 1 tote is a heavyweight nylon body with an adjustable strap with clip for hanging. Care differs: the Tough 1 listing states hand wash only and not water resistant, while the Derby listings state no care line at all. The bag side offers replaceable wear parts; the tote side states a simpler routine with stated limits.

Warranty and listing gaps

The Derby listings include a limited 6-month manufacturer’s warranty covering manufacturing defects; accidental damage and normal wear and tear are not covered. The Tough 1 listing includes 90-day coverage from JT International on defective materials or workmanship from point of purchase. Neither listing names goats; both are written for horses, and we report that as it stands. Our hay feeder vs hay net comparison covers the same horse-to-goat translation for wall feeders.

The gaps are worth a look before ordering. The Derby listings state no hanging measurements and no depth. The Tough 1 states no flake capacity and carries two conflicting dimension sets in its spec table. The black Derby spec table lists a 2 cups capacity that contradicts its own bullets. If any of those points decides your purchase, ask the seller before you order.

Which should you choose?

Choose a hay bag if you want stated 1.75 inch feed openings, a defined 2-3 flake capacity and a 6-month limited warranty, as the two Derby Originals examples show. The black and hunter green listings differ only in stated color and in the weight line, so pick by the color you prefer. For feeders that mount on the wall instead of hanging, see our goat hay feeders for wall.

Choose a hay net style feeder if you want one extra-large tote with a net front, a 2 by 2 inch poly rope feeding face and the lowest stated weight at 1.5 pounds, as the Tough 1 example shows. Our slow feed vs regular hay net guide shows where 2 inch openings sit among net sizes.

Whichever you pick, the listings describe their feeding claims as maker statements. Hang the feeder where goats can reach the openings without climbing, and check straps and clips for wear on a schedule you keep.

Around the Barn

  • Shake dust and debris out of the Super Tough Bottom before each refill.
  • Wipe the nylon bodies down as they soil; the Tough 1 listing states hand wash only.
  • Check the replaceable straps and snaps on the Derby bags for wear before refilling.
  • Keep a spare bag or tote on hand so one can dry while the other is in use.
  • Refill in the morning so hay stays fresh through the day’s feeding.

FAQs from goat keepers

Is a hay bag or hay net better for goats?

It depends on what you want stated. The Derby hay bags state 1.75 inch square openings and a 2-3 flake capacity. The Tough 1 net-front tote states 2 by 2 inch poly rope openings, extra-large sizing and a 1.5 pound weight. Neither listing names goats, so pick the side whose stated figures match your setup.

What size are the feed openings?

The Derby bags state 1.75 inch square openings in the front web. The Tough 1 net front states 2 by 2 inch poly rope openings. Smaller stated openings pace intake more; the listings do not state a rate.

How much hay do these feeders hold?

Both Derby bags state 2-3 flakes of hay. The Tough 1 tote states no flake count, only extra-large sizing and 29 by 21 by 7 inch dimensions, so its capacity is unclear from the listing.

Do these feeders come with a warranty?

The Derby bags include a limited 6-month manufacturer’s warranty covering manufacturing defects, excluding accidental damage and normal wear and tear. The Tough 1 tote includes 90-day coverage from JT International on defective materials or workmanship.

Can I hang these in a goat shelter?

The Derby bags state replaceable hanging straps and snaps, and the Tough 1 states an adjustable strap with clip. No hanging measurements are stated for any of the three, so measure your setup against the tote’s 29 by 21 by 7 inch dimensions before ordering.

Derby Slow Feeder Black
Still deciding? Our top pickDerby Slow Feeder Black
Check price on Amazon

Behind the Farm Score

Product GoatGear Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
Derby Slow Feeder Black 9.7 30 21 20 n/a 3
Derby Slow Feeder Hunter Green 9.6 29 20 19 n/a 3
Tough 1 Nylon Hay Tote 9.6 27 20 21 n/a 2

Our scores stay inside 9.2 and 9.8, with point totals stretched across that gap evenly, so the item with more points shows the bigger score. No power and no stated safety feature means no safety row: the score is then out of 90 points.

The GoatGear Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For hay feeders, safety points need a stated safety feature or certification; none of the three listings states one, so all three score zero there. The black Derby bag leads on the fullest spec table, the stated 2.5 pound weight and the 6-month warranty term. The hunter green Derby bag matches it on openings, flakes and warranty but states no weight. The Tough 1 tote earns points for the extra-large easy-load design and the 1.5 pound weight, and loses points for the missing capacity figure, the hand-wash-only care and the shorter 90-day coverage term. How we pick explains the weights.

More from the barn

See every hay feeder guide and all feeding and water guides.

More picks: hay nets for two goats, knotted vs knotless hay nets, hay ring vs hay net and hay nets for one goat.