
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Cattle Panel 4ft x 165ft 14 Gauge Galvanized Woven Wire Fence9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
DWALE Welded Wire Fence9.5/10View on Amazon - 3
HMOLIKH 4ft x 164ft Galvanized Farm Fence9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Black PVC Coated Welded Wire Fence 36" x 50' RollView on Amazon - 5
Welded Wire Fence 36inch x 50ft RollView on Amazon - 6
Cattle Fence 5ft x 164ftView on Amazon - 7
200 PCS T304 Stainless Steel Wire Fence ClipsView on Amazon - 8
Cat's Claw Fasteners Screw In Fence Staples for Wire FencingView on Amazon - 9
Fencer Wire Welded Wire Fence 12.5 GaugeView on Amazon
The morning chore starts with the goats rubbing their necks along the fence line, and you walking the wire to see what the night did to it. When goat owners ask about hog panels vs welded wire fence, they are really asking which one holds up to that daily rubbing with the least fiddling. Hog panels are rigid panels that stand stiff on their own; welded wire fence comes in flexible rolls you cut and tie to posts. This guide answers the question head on, then walks through four welded wire listings so you can see exactly what the numbers on a roll listing buy you.
Also worth comparing
Black PVC Coated Welded Wire Fence 36" x 50' RollCheck price on Amazon
Welded Wire Fence 36inch x 50ft RollCheck price on Amazon
Cattle Fence 5ft x 164ftCheck price on Amazon
200 PCS T304 Stainless Steel Wire Fence ClipsCheck price on Amazon
Cat's Claw Fasteners Screw In Fence Staples for Wire FencingCheck price on Amazon
Fencer Wire Welded Wire Fence 12.5 GaugeCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Hog panels vs welded wire fence: the short answer
Pick welded wire fence rolls when you need to cover a long run and follow uneven ground. The four rolls in this guide state 36 in x 50 ft or 48 in x 50 ft, and the listings say the flexible roll can be cut and attached to posts and frames. Pick hog panels when you want a short, stiff pen that stands without stretching, such as a kidding pen or a buck pen. For most goat yards, the rolls win on flexibility: GILPWA says its roll can be cut with scissors, YAGJIA says metal cutters, and YARDGARD says the roll attaches to posts and frames. Our goat panels vs woven wire fence guide covers the panel side of the family in more detail.
The four welded wire listings compared
| Listing | Roll size | Mesh | Wire | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| YARDGARD | 48 in x 50 ft | 2 in x 4 in | 14 gauge galvanized steel | 27.8 pounds |
| FOREHOGAR | 36 in x 50 ft | 2 in x 3 in | 16 gauge, black vinyl coated | 16.2 pounds |
| GILPWA | 36 in x 50 ft | 2 in x 2 in | 16 gauge, black vinyl coated | Not stated |
| YAGJIA | 36 in x 50 ft | 2 in x 3 in | 16 gauge, black vinyl coated | Not stated |
The tall roll: YARDGARD
YARDGARD states the tallest roll here: 48 in x 50 ft of 14 gauge galvanized steel wire with a 2 in x 4 in mesh, weighing 27.8 pounds. The bullets say the welded joints create a rigid structure that resists sagging and maintains spacing, and the galvanized steel is described as heavy duty with long-lasting rust resistance. This is the pick when you want the tallest stated height and the heaviest roll weight of the four at 27.8 pounds.
The coated 2 in x 3 in rolls: FOREHOGAR and YAGJIA
FOREHOGAR and YAGJIA read almost identically: a 36 in x 50 ft roll, 2 in x 3 in mesh, 16 gauge wire coated in black vinyl over galvanized steel. FOREHOGAR states the inner wire diameter as 16 gauge (1.5 mm), 1.9 mm after the vinyl coating, and a weight of 16.2 pounds; its bullets call the fence rustproof, which is the maker’s word. YAGJIA states the same 16 gauge (1.5 mm) inner wire, 14 gauge (1.9 mm) after coating, and adds extras the others do not: a pair of gloves, 15 U-shape hooks and 100 ties. YAGJIA also says the roll can be attached to a wood and steel frame or T posts and fixed in place with wire or zip ties. For temporary runs, see best temporary fence for goats.
The tight mesh: GILPWA
GILPWA states a 36 in x 50 ft roll with a 2 in x 2 in mesh, the smallest opening of the four, in 16 gauge black vinyl coated wire. It is the only listing of the four that states a warranty: 5 years. The bullets say the welded wire mesh can be cut with scissors and used with T posts or wooden boxes, which suits a DIY pen build.
Roll size and mesh
Roll height and mesh size decide what the fence holds. Three rolls state 36 in tall; the YARDGARD states 48 in tall. Mesh runs from 2 in x 2 in (GILPWA) through 2 in x 3 in (FOREHOGAR, YAGJIA) to 2 in x 4 in (YARDGARD). The listings aim the smaller meshes at small animals: FOREHOGAR says its 2 in x 3 in mesh keeps out deer, dogs, cats, rabbits or other small animals, and GILPWA lists poultry cages and rabbit pens among the uses for its 2 in x 2 in. Goats rub, lean and scratch on fence wire, so match the height and mesh to the animals you keep, not just the roll price of wire you need.
Gauge and coating
Wire gauge and coating decide how the fence ages outdoors. YARDGARD states 14 gauge galvanized steel with no coating; the other three state 16 gauge wire under a black vinyl coating over galvanized steel, which the makers describe as rustproof or rust resistant. FOREHOGAR and YAGJIA both state the inner wire at 1.5 mm, growing to 1.9 mm after the vinyl coating. Only GILPWA states a warranty term: 5 years. The other three state no warranty term. A coating makes the wire easier to wipe clean and hides it against dark posts, while plain galvanized wire keeps its zinc layer under no coating at all.
Hog panels: when rigid wins
Hog panels are rigid wire panels rather than rolls. None of the four listings here sells one, so there are no panel dimensions to compare in this guide; the strength of a panel is that it stands stiff without stretching or tensioning. That stiffness suits short, square pens where you do not want to stretch wire: a kidding pen, a sick pen, a buck pen or a garden corner the goats must not enter. Panels join with clips or rings, and our hog rings vs fence clips guide compares the two fasteners. Where a panel ends and a roll begins, many homesteaders run welded wire for the long runs and drop in panels for gates and corners.
Read the listing twice
Fence listings contradict themselves, and the conflicting numbers are usually the ones you need to plan the run:
- GILPWA: the title and bullets state 36 in x 50 ft, but the spec table lists Item Dimensions L x W as 300″L x 25″W, which does not match. Trust the title and bullets over the spec table.
- YAGJIA: the title and bullets state a 36 in x 50 ft roll of galvanized steel wire, but the spec table lists Size as 33FT and Material as Copper Wire, which does not match. Trust the title and bullets over the spec table.
- YARDGARD: the spec table lists Department as Teak and Manufacturer as Midwest Air Technology Inc, which have nothing to do with a fence roll. Trust the title and bullets over the spec table.
Measure the run before ordering and allow for the larger figure. If a number matters to your build, confirm it in the title and bullets, not just the spec table.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers fence hardware only: panel versus roll, roll sizes, mesh, gauge, coating and the listings’ own contradictions. It does not cover post spacing, how much fence a given herd needs, electric fence chargers or any animal health question. Ask your local extension office about fence layouts for your herd and pasture.
FAQs from goat keepers
Is a 36 in roll tall enough for a goat fence?
Three listings state 36 in tall and YARDGARD states 48 in tall. The listings state roll height, not a goat recommendation, so match the height to the goats you keep.
Which mesh size suits kids and small animals?
GILPWA states 2 in x 2 in, FOREHOGAR and YAGJIA state 2 in x 3 in, and YARDGARD states 2 in x 4 in. The listings aim the smaller meshes at small animals such as rabbits and poultry.
Do any of these rolls state a warranty?
Only GILPWA states one: a 5-year warranty. The other three listings state no warranty term.
Which listing includes installation extras?
YAGJIA includes a pair of gloves, 15 U-shape hooks and 100 ties. The other three listings state no extras.
Can welded wire rolls be cut to fit?
Yes, per the listings. YARDGARD says the roll can be cut and attached to posts and frames, GILPWA says it can be cut with scissors, and YAGJIA says it can be cut with metal cutters.
More from the barn
See every goat fencing guide and all fencing and shelter guides.
More picks: goat panels vs woven wire fence, electric netting vs welded wire, temporary fence for goats and chain link vs welded wire.
