Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Lithium vs AGM Fence Battery: Which One Should You Buy?

Lithium vs AGM fence battery: collar lithium cells and gel cell fence blocks compared on voltage, capacity and warranties.

Lithium vs AGM Fence Battery: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1SEFEPODER 12V 20Ah Lithium LiFePO4 Deep Cycle Battery 2-PackSEFEPODER 12V 20Ah Lithium LiFePO4 Deep Cycle Battery 2-Pack9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Mighty Max Battery ML7-6Mighty Max Battery ML7-69.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 32 Pack 12V 10Ah Lithium LiFePO4 Battery2 Pack 12V 10Ah Lithium LiFePO4 BatteryView on Amazon
  4. 412V 10Ah LiFePO4 Lithium Battery12V 10Ah LiFePO4 Lithium BatteryView on Amazon

Lithium vs AGM fence battery comes down to what you are powering. Lithium batteries here are small cells for receiver collars, light and long-lived on the shelf. AGM-style gel cell batteries here are heavy 6-volt and 12-volt blocks that run solar electric fence energizers. They are not interchangeable: a collar battery cannot run a fence charger, and a gel cell cannot fit a collar. This guide covers how to choose by voltage, capacity, use and the warranties the listings state, with four examples.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Lithium vs AGM fence battery: the short answer

Match the battery to the device. For a solar electric fence energizer, the listings here offer AGM-style gel cells: the Parmak 901 at 6 volts and 14 amp-hours, and the Parmak 902 at 12 volts. For a receiver collar on a dog fence system, the listings offer lithium cells: the Extreme Dog Fence 6-volt 5-pack and the Tyrone 3.6-volt 4-pack. Lithium wins on shelf life and weight for collars; gel cells win on capacity for energizers.

Two battery types compared

Type Example listing Stated voltage Use
Lithium, collar Extreme Dog Fence 6V 5-pack 6 volts Receiver collars
Lithium, collar Tyrone 3.6V 4-pack 3.6 volts Receiver collars, monitors
Gel cell (AGM-style) Parmak 901 6 volts, 14 Ah Solar electric fences
Gel cell (AGM-style) Parmak 902 12 volts Solar electric fences

Voltage and capacity

The gel cells state the clearest electrical specs. The Parmak 901 is a 6-volt 14 amp-hour gel cell for solar powered electric fences, weighing 4 pounds. The Parmak 902 is a 12-volt gel cell weighing 10.2 pounds in the bullets and 8 pounds in the spec table, a contradiction to note. The lithium collar cells are smaller: the Extreme Dog Fence pack is five 6-volt lithium ion cells at 2.08 ounces for the pack, and the Tyrone pack is four 3.6-volt 1200 mAh lithium cells. Capacity in amp-hours is stated only on the gel cells.

Rechargeable vs single use

The Parmak gel cells are rechargeable and listed for solar powered electric fences, which charge them from a panel. The Tyrone lithium cells are single use with a stated 10-year shelf life and a broad minus 60 to plus 85 Celsius temperature range. The Extreme Dog Fence lithium cells are described as long life and waterproof when sealed. For a collar you replace cells; for a fence energizer you recharge the block.

Warranties

The Tyrone lists a 30-day warranty. The Parmak 901 lists a warranty with no term given. The Parmak 902 lists no warranty. The Extreme Dog Fence lists no warranty term. A 30-day term is the only stated figure here.

The gear: four batteries, ranked

1. Tyrone 3.6V lithium 4-pack. The lithium pick with a stated warranty: four 3.6-volt 1200 mAh cells, single use, 10-year shelf life, compatible with DogWatch collars and others. 30-day warranty stated.

2. Parmak 901 6V gel cell. The 6-volt fence pick: 14 amp-hour gel cell for solar electric fences, 4 pounds, rechargeable. Warranty listed with no term.

3. Parmak 902 12V gel cell. The 12-volt fence pick for larger energizers. Note the weight contradiction: 10.2 pounds in the bullets against 8 pounds in the spec table. No warranty stated.

4. Extreme Dog Fence 6V 5-pack. Five 6-volt lithium ion collar cells, long life, waterproof when sealed. No warranty term stated.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers battery hardware only. It does not cover fence charger sizing, grounding or any animal health question. Match the battery voltage to your device, and ask the charger maker about capacity for your fence length.

FAQs from goat keepers

Can I use a lithium collar battery in a fence energizer?

No. The lithium listings here are small collar cells at 3.6 and 6 volts. Fence energizers use the gel cell blocks at 6 or 12 volts with amp-hour capacity.

What is the difference between the Parmak 901 and 902?

The 901 is a 6-volt 14 amp-hour gel cell at 4 pounds; the 902 is a 12-volt gel cell at 10.2 pounds in the bullets. Both are listed for solar powered electric fences.

How long do the lithium collar batteries last?

The Tyrone lists a 10-year shelf life and typical use of 2 years in some receivers and 1 year in others. The Extreme Dog Fence lists long life with no figure.

Which battery has a warranty?

The Tyrone with a stated 30-day warranty. The Parmak 901 lists a warranty with no term; the others state none.

More from the barn

See our AGM vs lead acid fence battery and lithium vs lead acid fence battery comparisons, and every fence charger guide.

More picks: AGM vs lead acid, lithium vs lead acid and fencing and shelter.