Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Poly vs Steel Stock Tank: Which One Should You Buy?

Poly vs steel stock tank, compared on two poly tank covers and two steel tanks: material, size, weight, warranty and which side suits your yard.

Top picks

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

How we score

Poly vs Steel Stock Tank: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Flame King YSN201b PropaneFlame King YSN201b Propane9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Dee Zee DZ91753SB TransferDee Zee DZ91753SB Transfer9.5/10View on Amazon
  3. 3YardJoyliz 9 Foot Tank CoverYardJoyliz 9 Foot Tank Cover9.4/10View on Amazon
  4. 4YardJoyliz 10 Foot Tank CoverYardJoyliz 10 Foot Tank Cover9.4/10View on Amazon

The poly vs steel stock tank question comes up when the morning water run turns into a chore and the old tank needs replacing. A poly tank is light and round, a steel tank is heavy and rigid, and the choice shapes how the tank moves, how it weathers and how long it lasts in the yard. We compared the listings on both sides using only what each Amazon listing publishes, with the poly side shown by covers sized for round poly tanks and the steel side shown by a propane cylinder and a transfer tank.

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Quick verdict: choose the poly side if you already own a round poly tank and want a cover that keeps leaves, bugs and dirt out of the water, as the YardJoyliz covers show in 9 foot and 10 foot sizes. Choose the steel side if you need a steel tank, as the Flame King propane cylinder and the Dee Zee transfer tank show. A buyer shopping for a goat water tank will not find one among these four listings.

Four examples

Flame King YSN201b Propane

Flame King YSN201b Propane

Flame King9.6/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 20 pound steel propane cylinder with a Type 1 overflow protection device valve, powder-coated and DOT approved, that ships empty and pre-purged.

Pros

  • 20 pound steel cylinder with a Type 1 overflow protection device valve
  • DOT approved valve assembly
  • High-grade steel-welded construction with a powder-coated exterior
  • Ships empty and pre-purged, ready to be filled with gas

Cons

  • A propane cylinder, not a water tank for goats
  • Holds propane, not water, so no water capacity is stated
  • Warranty term is 30 days only
  • Ships empty, so it needs a fill before first use
Dee Zee DZ91753SB Transfer

Dee Zee DZ91753SB Transfer

DEE ZEE9.5/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 106 gallon rectangle steel transfer tank in 14-gauge steel with a black powder coat finish and a radius curve that eliminates weld pressure points.

Pros

  • 106 gallon capacity in a rectangle steel tank
  • Heavy-duty 14-gauge steel with a black powder coat finish for corrosion protection
  • Radius curve eliminates weld pressure points
  • 48 by 24 by 24 inches, a large fixed tank for the yard

Cons

  • A transfer tank, not a water tank for goats
  • 160.0 pounds, heavy to move once it is placed
  • No warranty term is stated
  • 48 by 24 by 24 inches, so it takes a large patch of level ground
YardJoyliz 9 Foot Tank Cover

YardJoyliz 9 Foot Tank Cover

YardJoyliz9.4/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A black plastic cover sized for a 9 foot round stock tank that keeps leaves, bugs and dirt out of the water.

Pros

  • Sized for a 9 foot round plastic stock tank
  • Keeps leaves, bugs and dirt out of the water
  • Black color draws extra heat into the water, as the maker states
  • Easy to put in place, and one person can do it

Cons

  • A cover, not a tank: it needs a 9 foot round tank underneath
  • Fits round tanks only, not rectangle tanks
  • Two people are better for putting it in place
  • Only 0.004 inches thick, so it is a light cover rather than a rigid lid
YardJoyliz 10 Foot Tank Cover

YardJoyliz 10 Foot Tank Cover

YardJoyliz9.4/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A black plastic cover sized for a 10 foot round stock tank that keeps leaves, bugs and dirt out of the water.

Pros

  • Sized for a 10 foot round plastic stock tank
  • Keeps leaves, bugs and dirt out of the water
  • Black color draws extra heat into the water, as the maker states
  • Easy to put in place, and one person can do it

Cons

  • A cover, not a tank: it needs a 10 foot round tank underneath
  • Fits round tanks only, not rectangle tanks
  • Two people are better for putting it in place
  • No warranty term is stated

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


Also worth comparing

Poly vs steel stock tank: side by side

Tank GoatGear Score Side Size Capacity Warranty Amazon
Flame King YSN201b Propane 9.6/10 Steel 12.0 x 12.0 x 17.8 inches 20 pounds 30 day warranty View on Amazon
Dee Zee DZ91753SB Transfer 9.5/10 Steel 48 x 24 x 24 inches 106 gallons Not stated View on Amazon
YardJoyliz 9 Foot Tank Cover 9.4/10 Poly 9 foot round Not stated Not stated View on Amazon
YardJoyliz 10 Foot Tank Cover 9.4/10 Poly 10 foot round Not stated Not stated View on Amazon

Every spec repeats the brand’s rating from its listing (collected on 18 November 2026).

What each side is made of

The poly side in these listings is plastic. Both YardJoyliz listings are covers for plastic round stock tanks, in black, and the maker states the black color draws extra heat into the water. A cover is not a tank: it sits on top of a round poly tank and keeps leaves, bugs and dirt out of the water. Flame King lists high-grade steel-welded construction with a powder-coated exterior on its 20 pound propane cylinder, and Dee Zee lists heavy-duty 14-gauge steel with a texture black powder coat finish for corrosion protection on its transfer tank. See our galvanized vs plastic water trough comparison for more on trough materials.

Material shapes the daily job. A plastic cover lifts off easily for the morning water check, while a steel tank stays where it is placed. The powder coat on both steel listings is stated as exterior protection, and the Dee Zee radius curve is stated to eliminate weld pressure points.

Size and capacity

The poly covers come in two round sizes, 9 foot and 10 foot, sized to fit round plastic stock tanks. The steel side is measured differently: the Flame King cylinder is 12.0 by 12.0 by 17.8 inches and holds 20 pounds of propane, and the Dee Zee transfer tank is 48 by 24 by 24 inches with a stated capacity of 106 gallons.

The poly listings state no water capacity, since they are covers, while the steel listings state what they hold: 20 pounds of propane in the Flame King cylinder and 106 gallons in the Dee Zee transfer tank. None of these four listings states a water capacity for goats. Our water trough sizes guide lists more gallons and dimensions.

Weight and moving them

The poly covers are light lids that one person can put in place, though the maker states two people are better. The Flame King cylinder lists 18.0 pounds, and the Dee Zee transfer tank lists 160.0 pounds.

A light cover suits a round tank that gets checked daily, an 18.0 pound cylinder is a portable propane tank for grilling, camping and heating, and a 160.0 pound transfer tank is a fixed steel tank.

Warranty and listing gaps to check

Only one of the four listings states a warranty term. Flame King states a 30 day warranty that voids if not purchased from Amazon Retail. The two YardJoyliz covers and the Dee Zee transfer tank state no warranty term. Neither poly cover states a water capacity, and the Dee Zee listing leaves its capacity and size unclear, so a buyer who needs exact figures should ask the seller before ordering.

Which should you choose?

Choose the poly side if you already own a round poly tank and want a cover that keeps leaves, bugs and dirt out of the water, as the YardJoyliz covers show in 9 foot and 10 foot sizes.

Choose the steel side if you need a steel tank, as the Flame King propane cylinder shows at 20 pounds with a DOT approved valve, or the Dee Zee transfer tank shows at 106 gallons in 14-gauge steel. If you need a water tank for goats, none of these four listings is one. Our water troughs for goats roundup lists troughs built for goats.

Whichever side you pick, check the stated size against the tank you own before ordering, since the listings here leave some figures unclear.

Around the Barn

  • Match the cover to the tank: the YardJoyliz covers fit 9 foot and 10 foot round plastic tanks.
  • Put the cover in place with two people; one person can do it, but two are better.
  • Lift the cover to clear leaves, bugs and dirt before they reach the water.
  • Set the 160.0 pound steel transfer tank on level ground, since it is heavy to move once placed.

FAQs from goat keepers

Is a poly or steel stock tank better for goats?

Neither side wins outright from these listings. The poly side here is covers for 9 foot and 10 foot round tanks, and the steel side is a 20 pound propane cylinder and a 106 gallon transfer tank. Pick poly if you already own a round poly tank; pick steel if you need a propane cylinder or a transfer tank.

How heavy is a steel stock tank?

It varies by listing. The Flame King cylinder lists 18.0 pounds, and the Dee Zee transfer tank lists 160.0 pounds.

Does a poly stock tank need a cover?

A cover is not required, but the YardJoyliz covers keep leaves, bugs and dirt out of the water and keep the water warm and clean. They fit 9 foot and 10 foot round plastic tanks.

What warranty comes with these tanks?

Only one listing states a term: Flame King states a 30 day warranty that voids if not purchased from Amazon Retail. The YardJoyliz covers and the Dee Zee transfer tank state no warranty term.

Flame King YSN201b Propane
Still deciding? Our top pickFlame King YSN201b Propane
Check price on Amazon

Behind the Farm Score

Product GoatGear Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
Flame King YSN201b Propane 9.6 29 21 20 8 3
Dee Zee DZ91753SB Transfer 9.5 26 20 19 5 0
YardJoyliz 9 Foot Tank Cover 9.4 29 20 20 0 0
YardJoyliz 10 Foot Tank Cover 9.4 28 20 20 0 0

We translate each weighted point total onto the 9.2 through 9.8 band; ranks never flip, because the conversion is linear.

The GoatGear Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For stock tanks, safety points need stated safety features or certifications, such as the DOT approved valve on the Flame King cylinder or the radius curve on the Dee Zee tank; the two poly covers state none, so both score zero there. Only the Flame King states a warranty term, 30 days, so it is the only one with warranty points. How we pick explains the weights.

More from the barn

See every goat water troughs guide and all goat feeding guides.

More picks: water troughs for goats, galvanized vs plastic water troughs, water trough sizes and round stock tanks.