Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Cedar vs Locust Fence Posts: Which One Should You Buy?

Cedar vs locust fence posts: what four Amazon listings say about protecting wood fence posts, from copper post caps to steel repair stakes.

Cedar vs Locust Fence Posts: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1ARKSOLDIER 33.62 in Fence Post Repair KitARKSOLDIER 33.62 in Fence Post Repair Kit9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Grazeline Fence Post Repair Kit 2-PackGrazeline Fence Post Repair Kit 2-Pack9.7/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Postsaver Pro-Set Fast Fixing Foam for Fence and Deck PostsPostsaver Pro-Set Fast Fixing Foam for Fence and Deck Posts9.7/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Heavy Duty Steel Fence Post Repair StakesHeavy Duty Steel Fence Post Repair StakesView on Amazon
  5. 5Wooden Cedar Post Caps Rot ResistantWooden Cedar Post Caps Rot ResistantView on Amazon
  6. 6Fence Posts 7FTFence Posts 7FTView on Amazon
  7. 7XtremepowerUS 1500W Electric Post Hole Digger Earth Auger DigXtremepowerUS 1500W Electric Post Hole Digger Earth Auger DigView on Amazon
  8. 81 Pack 24 Inch Black Fence Post Driver with Handle 34LB Iron1 Pack 24 Inch Black Fence Post Driver with Handle 34LB IronView on Amazon

Ask a fence builder whether cedar or locust posts last longer and you will get a strong opinion either way. The four listings we compared for this guide do not settle that argument; they are not posts at all. They are the gear that protects whichever wood you set: post caps that keep rain off the top of the post, and steel stakes that repair a wobbly post without digging it out. So the short version of cedar vs locust fence posts is this: pick your wood, then protect it, because the listings agree that water on the post top and wobble at the base are what kill a fence. Every number below comes from one of the four listings, and we point out where those listings contradict themselves.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Cedar vs locust fence posts: the short answer

None of these listings compares cedar and locust wood against each other, so this guide does not crown a winner. What the listings do say, consistently, is that a wood post fails at two places: the top, where rain sits and rot starts, and the base, where the post goes wobbly in the ground. The gear below addresses both. Post caps from Tandefio, Geetery and Hosuly cover the post top so water sheds instead of soaking in; the Tandefio listing says its angled cap surfaces lower the risk of wood rot. Steel repair stakes from Epcee brace a tilted or broken post back upright without pulling it out of the ground. Buy the posts your local yard stocks, then spend the gear money on caps and stakes.

If you would rather go straight to the gear, our best electric fence for goats roundup covers the wire side of the fence.

The four listings compared

Gear Type Stated size What it does
Epcee Fence Post Repair Stakes Repair stake, 4-pack 33.6 in tall, 17.7 in ground depth Braces tilted or broken wood posts
Tandefio Copper Post Caps Post cap, 2-pack Fits 5.5 x 5.5 in posts Pyramid cap sheds rain off the post top
Hosuly Cedar Ball Post Caps Post cap, 4-pack Fits 3.5 x 3.5 in posts Cedar cap with ball finial, rot resistant stated
Geetery Cedar Post Caps Post cap, 8-pack Size claims conflict (see below) Cedar cap stated to help extend post life

Steel repair stakes

The Epcee listing sells a 4-pack of U-shaped steel stakes, 1/8 by 2 in channel, 33.6 in tall with a 17.7 in ground depth, each pack weighing 5 lb. You drive the stake into the soil beside the post with a big hammer, the listing recommends 5 lb or more, then lock the included screws, 2 by 5/16 in hex screws, 16 of them, into the wood post. The H-design spike is described as stronger than a straight spike and able to bypass the concrete around the post. Installing on both sides of the post makes it more stable, per the listing. This is the only pick that fixes a post already in the ground, which makes it the most useful item here for an existing fence.

Copper post caps

The Tandefio listing sells 2 solid copper pyramid post caps with 2 screws each, designed to fit 5.5 by 5.5 in square posts, with outer dimensions of about 5.66 by 5.66 in and a height of about 1.34 in. The pyramid shape has angled surfaces that stop rain, snow and leaves from resting on the top, which the listing says lowers the risk of wood rot and metal rust. Solid copper is the premium material here, and the listing notes the caps add an aesthetic appeal to the fence. Check the size before ordering, as the listing itself advises.

Cedar post caps

The Hosuly listing sells 4 cedar post caps with a pine ball finial, fitting nominal 4 by 4 in wood posts with 3-5/8 by 3-5/8 in inside dimensions; the overall size is about 5.31 by 5.31 by 5.12 in. The cedar is stated to offer natural resistance to decay in warm and cold weather, and the caps protect against weather and insects. The caps are reusable, per the listing. The Geetery listing sells 8 cedar post caps in a natural cedar color, stated to help extend post life and resist various weather conditions, installed with trimming nails or caulking, which are not included.

Post tops: where rot starts

Every post cap listing tells the same story: water sitting on a flat post top soaks in and rot follows. The Tandefio pyramid cap sheds rain, snow and leaves off the angled top. The Geetery cedar caps cover the top and the listing says they help extend post life. The Hosuly caps add a ball finial on top of the cedar cover. Whichever cap you choose, the size has to match the post: the Tandefio fits 5.5 by 5.5 in posts, while the Hosuly fits 3.5 by 3.5 in posts. A cap that does not fit is decoration, not protection.

Cedar caps on cedar posts are the natural pairing, and the Hosuly listing leans on cedar’s stated natural resistance to decay. But a cap protects any wood post, cedar or locust, because the mechanism is the same: keep standing water off the end grain. If your posts are locust, a cedar cap still sheds the rain.

Post bases: where wobble starts

A post that rocks in its hole will not hold wire tension, and goats lean on fences. The Epcee repair stakes address this without the digging: the 33.6 in stake goes 17.7 in into the ground beside the post, the H-design works around existing concrete, and the screws lock the stake to the wood. The listing recommends a 5 lb or heavier hammer and says installing stakes on both sides of the post makes it more stable. If the post itself is broken at the base, the stake braces the break; if the post is sound but loose, the stake re-anchors it. Either way, you are not pulling concrete out of the ground.

For new fence builds, see our fence post drivers guide before you set the first post.

Read the listing twice

These listings contradict themselves, and the numbers that conflict are the ones you need to match gear to posts:

  • Epcee: the bullets say S275-channel steel while the spec table says A6 Tool Steel. The size is given as 4.72 by 2 by 33.6 in in the bullets and the weight as 5 lb per pack against 5 pounds in the spec table, which agree.
  • Tandefio: the title and size field say 6 by 6 in with an actual fit of 5.5 by 5.5 in, the bullets give outer dimensions of about 5.66 by 5.66 in, and one spec field says 3.5 by 3.5 in, which disagrees with everything else. Trust the 5.5 by 5.5 in fit.
  • Geetery: the title says 6 by 6 in caps for 5.5 by 5.5 in posts, the bullets say each cap is about 4 by 4 in fitting 3.5 by 3.5 in posts, and the spec table says 6 by 6 in. This is the messiest size claim of the four; confirm the actual size before ordering.
  • Hosuly: the title says 4 by 4 in with an actual 3-5/8 in inside dimension, the bullets say it fits true 3.5 by 3.5 in posts, and the product dimensions are 5.25 by 5.25 by 6.1 in. The fit figures agree; the product dimensions describe the cap itself.

Measure your posts before ordering and allow for the larger figure. The Tandefio listing says it outright: check the size before ordering.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers post protection gear only. It does not compare cedar and locust wood on rot resistance, lifespan or cost, because none of the listings we compared states those figures. It does not cover wire, chargers or gates. Ask your local lumber yard or extension office about which post wood suits your soil and climate.

FAQs from goat keepers

Do post caps really extend the life of a wood fence post?

The Geetery listing says its cedar caps help extend post life, and the Tandefio listing says its angled caps lower the risk of wood rot by shedding rain, snow and leaves. These are maker claims, but the mechanism, keeping water off the post top, is the same in every cap listing.

What size post cap fits my fence posts?

Measure the post. The Tandefio caps fit 5.5 by 5.5 in posts, the Hosuly caps fit 3.5 by 3.5 in posts, and the Geetery size claims conflict, so confirm before ordering. A cap must match the post to protect it.

Can I fix a wobbly fence post without digging it out?

The Epcee listing says yes: drive the 33.6 in steel stake 17.7 in into the ground beside the post, then screw the stake to the post with the included 2 by 5/16 in screws. The H-design works around existing concrete.

Are cedar post caps only for cedar posts?

No. The Hosuly and Geetery caps are made of cedar, but a cap sheds water off any wood post top. The Tandefio listing even names cedar, wood and metal posts among the fits for its copper caps.

More from the barn

See every fencing and shelter guide and all goat shelters guides.

More picks: electric fences for goats, goat fencing wire, fence post drivers.