
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
MIWEVRO Metal Garden Fence Posts9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
CLEASO Metal Fence Posts9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
VEVOR 6 ft U-Channel Metal Fence Post9.7/10View on Amazon - 4
Heavy Duty Steel Fence Post Repair StakesView on Amazon - 5
Sasylvia Wooden Cedar Post Caps Rot ResistantView on Amazon - 6
Fence Posts 7FTView on Amazon - 7
XtremepowerUS 1500W Electric Post Hole Digger Earth Auger DigView on Amazon - 8
1 Pack 24 Inch Black Fence Post Driver with Handle 34LB IronView on Amazon
A goat rubbing its head on a fence post will find every weak spot in the fence line, and cedar vs redwood fence posts is the question that decides how long those posts last. The listings we compared cover cedar post caps, a copper post cap and steel repair stakes; no redwood product is listed. Cedar wins on the evidence here: two listings are cedar caps with stated rot resistance, and the rest protect or repair wood posts of either species. Both woods show up in fencing catalogs, but these four listings document cedar, copper and steel only.
Also worth comparing
Heavy Duty Steel Fence Post Repair StakesCheck price on Amazon
Sasylvia Wooden Cedar Post Caps Rot ResistantCheck price on Amazon
Fence Posts 7FTCheck price on Amazon
XtremepowerUS 1500W Electric Post Hole Digger Earth Auger DigCheck price on Amazon
1 Pack 24 Inch Black Fence Post Driver with Handle 34LB IronCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Cedar vs redwood fence posts: the short answer
Choose cedar if you are buying from these listings: the Geetery and Hosuly caps are cedar with stated resistance to weather and decay, and the Tandefio copper cap is sized for cedar fences. No listing here sells redwood posts or compares the two woods directly, so treat any redwood claim from elsewhere as unstated. Whatever wood the posts are, cap the tops and fix tilted posts early: that is what the four listings below are for. Measure the post tops before ordering: 3.5-inch and 5.5-inch posts take different caps. For the treated-wood question, see our cedar vs pressure treated fence posts guide.
Post caps: what the cedar listings state
The Geetery listing is an 8-pack of cedar post caps sized for 3.5 x 3.5 inch wood posts, with inside dimensions of 3-5/8 x 3-5/8 inches and a cap about 4 x 4 inches with 1.5 inches of internal height. The listing calls the cedar sturdy and weather resistant, and says the caps install with trimming nails or exterior caulk, which are not included. The Hosuly listing is a 4-pack of cedar caps with a pine ball finial, fitting nominal 4 x 4 inch posts (true 3.5 x 3.5 inches), with external dimensions of about 5.31 x 5.31 x 5.12 inches. It states natural resistance to decay in warm and cold weather and installs with studs or exterior caulk.
The Tandefio listing is a pair of solid copper pyramid caps for about 5.5 x 5.5 inch square posts, with outer dimensions of about 5.66 x 5.66 inches and a height of about 1.34 inches. The sloped cap sheds rain, snow and leaves, and the copper is UV and heat resistant and non-corrodible. The listing says the copper turns green over time for an antique look, or keep it polished with a clear lacquer outdoor spray, and that the caps last a lifetime with no maintenance. For fastening caps and wire, see our best fence staples for wood posts.
Repair stakes for tilted posts
The Epcee listing is a 4-pack of heavy-duty U-shaped steel repair stakes for tilted or broken wood fence posts. Each stake is 4.72 x 2 x 33.6 inches with a 17.7-inch ground depth and weighs 5 pounds. The set includes 16 hexagonal screws (2 x 5/16 inch), a hex socket (max 1/2 inch) and a drill bit (3/16 inch). Installation uses a big hammer of 5 lbs or more driven into the soil parallel to the post, with screws locking into the wood; doing both sides makes the post more stable.
The gear, ranked
Ranked by how directly each listing serves a wood-post fence: the Geetery 8-pack of cedar caps first, for the most caps per order and stated weather resistance; the Hosuly 4-pack of cedar ball-top caps second, for stated rot resistance and the decorative finial; the Tandefio copper caps third, for a lifetime, no-maintenance cap sized for cedar fences; the Epcee steel repair stakes fourth, for straightening tilted or broken posts rather than protecting new ones.
Read the listing twice
Three listings contradict themselves on size. The Tandefio title says 6 x 6 inches while the bullets say the caps fit about 5.5 x 5.5 inch posts; the spec table even lists 3.5 x 3.5 inches. Trust the bullets: about 5.5 x 5.5. The Geetery title says 6 x 6 caps for 5.5 x 5.5 posts while the bullets say the caps fit 3.5 x 3.5 inch posts at about 4 x 4 inches. Trust the bullets: 3.5 x 3.5. The Hosuly bullets give 5.31 x 5.31 x 5.12 inches while the spec table gives 5.25 x 5.25 x 6.1. Trust the bullets.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers post caps and repair stakes only. It does not cover setting new posts, concrete, or any health question. No redwood products were listed, so nothing here compares redwood directly.
FAQs from goat keepers
Which cap fits a 4×4 post?
The Geetery and Hosuly caps fit nominal 4 x 4 inch posts, which measure a true 3.5 x 3.5 inches. The Tandefio caps fit larger posts of about 5.5 x 5.5 inches.
Are the cedar caps treated?
The Hosuly listing states a pressure treated ball top on a cedar cap. The Geetery listing describes natural cedar with no treatment stated.
How do the repair stakes install?
Drive the stake with a big hammer of 5 lbs or more into the soil to the 17.7-inch ground depth, parallel to the post, then lock the screws into the wood. Doing both sides makes the post more stable.
Do the copper caps need maintenance?
The listing states they last a lifetime with no maintenance. The copper turns green over time; spray with clear lacquer outdoor spray to keep the polished look.
How many pieces come in each pack?
Eight cedar caps in the Geetery pack, four in the Hosuly pack, two copper caps in the Tandefio pack, and four steel stakes in the Epcee pack.
Can the repair stakes fix a rotted post?
The listing covers tilted or broken wood fence posts. It does not state a use for fully rotted posts.
More from the barn
See every Goat Fencing guide and all Fencing and Shelter guides.
More picks: cedar vs pressure treated posts, fence staples for wood posts, T-post vs rebar and goat panels vs woven wire.
