
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
MIWEVRO Metal Garden Fence Posts9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
CLEASO Metal Fence Posts9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
VEVOR 6 ft U-Channel Metal Fence Post9.7/10View on Amazon
Cedar vs pressure treated fence posts comes down to how each resists rot: cedar is stated in the listings as naturally resistant to rot and decay, while pressure treated posts rely on chemical treatment and are the most common size stocked. One honest note before the guide: the four listings provided for this article are post caps, the covers that protect post tops from weather, not the posts themselves. Two are cedar caps, one is an ASA cap in a cedar color sized for pressure treated posts, and one is aluminum. Every number below comes from those listings.
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Cedar vs pressure treated fence posts: the short answer
Cedar brings stated natural resistance to rot and decay, per the Deckorators listing, which calls red cedar strong and naturally resistant. Pressure treated posts are the standard dimensional lumber of fencing: the Atlanta Post Caps listing titles its 6×6 cap for the 5.5 inch size as the most common size for pressure treated posts. Cedar costs more per post and weathers to gray; pressure treated is cheaper and uniform but the treatment does not cover cuts, so sealed cuts and protected tops matter on both. Either way, the post top is the weak point, which is where caps come in.
Rot resistance: what the listings state
The Deckorators cap listing states red cedar is naturally resistant to rot and decay for long lasting performance. The Geetery cedar caps state resistance against various weather conditions, with one warning: do not expose them to the sun after rain, as it may cause cracking. That is the trade of a natural material stated plainly. Pressure treated wood gets no rot claim in these listings because the listings sell caps, not posts; what the Atlanta listing confirms is that 5.5 inch square is the common pressure treated size to fit.
Protecting the post top: four caps from the listings
Post caps keep water off the end grain, where rot starts. The four listings cover the main materials:
- Deckorators 4×4 cedar cap: real red cedar with stated natural rot resistance, 7.1 oz, interior 3-5/8 inch for true 4×4 posts. The listing states both a 2 year limited warranty in the bullets and a 90 day limited warranty in the spec table, so confirm before buying.
- Geetery cedar caps, 8 pack: cedar material with stated weather resistance and original grain, 8.56 lbs for the pack. The listing warns against sun after rain to avoid cracking, and the size text mixes 6×6 with 4×4 and 3.5 inch figures, so measure your posts first.
- Atlanta Post Caps 6×6: ASA plastic in a Cedar color, 6.3 oz, for 5.5 inch posts, the common pressure treated size. Color, not wood: it looks like cedar without cedar’s maintenance.
- Azdele 4×4 aluminum caps, 4 pack: aluminum alloy with powder-coat paint, stated 100% anti-corrosion and rust-proof and UV-protected, 1.19 lbs for the pack, with a stated one-year warranty. The metal option that never rots because it is not wood.
Reading the listing twice
These listings contradict themselves in places worth catching. The Deckorators bullets promise a 2 year limited warranty while the spec table says 90 day limited warranty. The Atlanta cap is titled Cedar but the material is ASA plastic in a Cedar color. The Geetery title says 6×6 for 5.5×5.5 posts while the size details describe 4 inch caps fitting 3.5 inch posts. The Azdele title says brown while the bullets describe a matte black cap. None of this kills a purchase, but measure your posts and confirm the warranty before ordering. See fence post best practices for setting posts that stay put.
What this guide does not cover
This guide does not rate post lifespan in years, treatment chemical types, or installed cost per post, because none of the four listings states those figures. For post material matchups see wood vs steel fence posts and cedar vs pine fence posts. For setting method see fence post driving vs concrete.
FAQs from goat keepers
Is cedar naturally rot resistant?
The Deckorators listing states red cedar is strong and naturally resistant to rot and decay.
What size cap fits a pressure treated 6×6 post?
The Atlanta listing fits 5.5 inch square posts, which it calls the most common pressure treated size.
Do cedar caps need maintenance?
The Geetery listing warns not to expose cedar caps to sun after rain, as it may cause cracking.
Which cap has a stated warranty?
The Azdele states a one-year warranty. The Deckorators states 2 years in the bullets and 90 days in the spec table.
Are post caps hard to install?
The Azdele includes screws for a 4 pack install, and the Deckorators attaches with exterior-grade silicone adhesive per the listing.
More from the barn
See every fencing and shelter guide and all goat fencing guides.
More picks: wood vs steel fence posts and cedar vs pine fence posts.
