Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Wood vs Metal Livestock Gate: Which One Should You Buy?

Wood vs metal livestock gate choices compared on stated size, mounting, material and pack count, from wooden pet gates to steel electric fence gate anchors.

Wood vs Metal Livestock Gate: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Goovilla Fence Post Repair KitGoovilla Fence Post Repair Kit9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2HILLMASTER Key-Lockable 2-Sided Gate Latch for MetalHILLMASTER Key-Lockable 2-Sided Gate Latch for Metal9.6/10View on Amazon

Morning chores go faster when the gate swings the way you expect and shuts behind you without a fight, and a gate that sticks turns a simple trip to the barn into a wrestling match. This guide covers wood vs metal livestock gate choices by material, stated size, mounting and pack count. The listings compared here are wooden pet gates and steel electric fence gate anchors, and no full metal gate panel is among them, so the metal side of this comparison is gate hardware for electric fence gates on wood posts. Every number below comes from a listing for a product we compared, and we point out where those listings give conflicting figures.

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Wood vs metal livestock gate: the short answer

Choose wood when the job is blocking a doorway, hallway or stairwell inside a building. The MidWest Homes for Pets gate expands from 50.25 to 94 inches wide and stands 24 inches tall, and The Wooden Town gate covers 72 inches wide at 24 inches tall with 4 panels. Choose steel gate anchors when the job is opening and closing an electric fence gate on a post. The EFencSolv anchors screw into wood posts and connect with electric fence spring, bungy cord or tape and rope, and the Gisafai anchors fit wood or steel T posts. The opening you need to close and the post you have settle it.

If you would rather look at gate hardware on its own, our metal gate hardware kit roundup covers that side of the fence line.

Wooden gates and steel gate anchors compared

Listing Material Stated size Mounting
MidWest Homes for Pets Extra-Wide Swing Pet Safety Gate Wood Expands from 50.25 to 94 inches wide, 24 inches tall Hardware-mounted with four wall-mount brackets
The Wooden Town Dog Gate Solid wood and MDF 72 inches wide, 24 inches tall, 4 panels Free-standing, no wall mounting
EFencSolv Electric Fence Gate Handle Anchors Galvanized steel rings, plastic body 30 pack; anchor size Not stated Screw-in for wood posts
Gisafai Electric Fence Gate Handle Anchors Hardened steel and plastic 6 pack; plastic to screw length about 3.2 inches Screw-in for wood or steel T posts

Wooden gates

The MidWest Homes for Pets gate is built with wood balusters and a neutral finish. A spring-loaded latch allows quick opening, the gate swings open and closes shut, and the maker lists a weight of 6.3 pounds and a 1 year manufacturer warranty. The Wooden Town gate is made with solid wood and MDF in a hand carved design. It folds for moving, comes fully assembled and stands on its own with no wall mounting, which suits doorways, hallways and stairs where you want a divider you can shift from room to room.

Steel gate anchors

The EFencSolv anchors carry double hook 2-rings made of galvanized steel, and both rings are conductive and can be connected to both sides of the electric fence. The round plastic part is molded in one piece, the opening of one ring is designed to be very small so the hook does not slip out, and the rings are fixed so they will not move or slide to one side. The Gisafai anchors list a double hook length of approximately 3.4 inches and each hook and loop hole about 0.9 inches, with both rings conductive and fixed.

Size and fit

Wooden gates are sized by the opening they cover. The MidWest Homes for Pets gate expands from 50.25 to 94 inches wide, so measure the doorway, hallway or stairwell before you order and check that your opening falls inside that range. The Wooden Town gate covers 72 inches wide with 4 panels at 18 inches wide each, and each panel stands 24 inches tall. Steel anchors are sized by post and hook. The Gisafai anchors list a fixed wooden post diameter of about 1.7 inches, a plastic to screw length of about 3.2 inches and a double hook length of approximately 3.4 inches. The EFencSolv listing gives no anchor measurements, so the size to compare there is Not stated.

Mounting and posts

Mounting decides how fixed the gate is and how much work the install takes. The MidWest Homes for Pets gate is hardware-mounted and includes four wall-mount brackets with screws for a permanent installation, and the gate removes easily for storage when not in use. The Wooden Town gate needs no wall mounting at all, because the free-standing design provides stability on its own. On the metal side, the EFencSolv screw-in design is made specially for wood posts and can be mounted on any wood post, while the Gisafai anchors install on wood or steel T post gate posts by adjusting the position and rotating the screw nut to fix the insulator on the post. Match the anchor to the post you already have in the ground, and look at hinges for wood gates when a swinging wooden gate is part of the plan.

Materials: wood, MDF and steel

Material sets where each product belongs and how it weathers daily use. The listings we compared use four materials:

  • Wood: the MidWest Homes for Pets gate, built with wood balusters and a neutral finish.
  • Solid wood and MDF: The Wooden Town gate, in a hand carved design with a burnt finish.
  • Galvanized steel with plastic: the EFencSolv anchors, with conductive rings on a molded plastic body.
  • Hardened steel with plastic: the Gisafai anchors, primarily black in color.

Wooden gates suit indoor openings and finished rooms where the gate is part of the house. Steel anchors suit outdoor fence lines, where the conductive rings carry the electric fence connection across the gate opening. For background on fence types, see our guide to types of electric fence.

Pack counts and what is in the box

Pack count matters when a fence line has more than a single gate. The EFencSolv package includes 30 fence post anchors, and the Gisafai package includes 6 T post insulators, so count your gate posts before you order. The MidWest Homes for Pets gate includes four wall-mount brackets with screws, and The Wooden Town gate comes fully assembled with no assembly needed. Warranty terms differ as well: the MidWest Homes for Pets gate carries a 1 year manufacturer warranty, and the warranty term for the other listings is Not stated.

Read the listing twice

Gate listings can give conflicting figures, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones you need to plan the install:

  • The Wooden Town: the maker gives product dimensions of 72.0 x 72.0 x 24.0 inches alongside a panel size of 72 inches wide by 24 inches tall; check before ordering.
  • MidWest Homes for Pets: the maker gives a height of 24 inches tall alongside product dimensions of 1.75 x 50.25 x 24.125 inches; check before ordering.

Measure your doorway or post before ordering and allow for the larger figure where the maker gives conflicting numbers.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers gate hardware and pet gates only. It does not cover fencing for a whole pasture, animal health or any veterinary question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about goat health.

FAQs from goat keepers

Is wood or metal better for a livestock gate?

It depends on the job. The wooden gates in this guide block doorways, hallways and stairwells, with the MidWest Homes for Pets gate expanding from 50.25 to 94 inches wide. The steel anchors serve electric fence gates on posts, and no full metal gate panel is among the listings compared here.

How wide are the wooden gates in this guide?

The MidWest Homes for Pets gate expands from 50.25 to 94 inches wide at 24 inches tall. The Wooden Town gate covers 72 inches wide at 24 inches tall with 4 panels at 18 inches wide each.

Do the steel anchors fit steel posts?

The Gisafai anchors install on wood or steel T post gate posts. The EFencSolv screw-in design is made specially for wood posts, and the listing gives a fixed wooden post diameter of about 1.7 inches for the Gisafai anchors.

How many anchors come in a pack?

The EFencSolv package includes 30 fence post anchors. The Gisafai package includes 6 T post insulators with a plastic to screw length of about 3.2 inches and a double hook length of approximately 3.4 inches.

More from the barn

See every goat fencing guide and all fencing and shelter guides.

More picks: metal gate hardware kits, hinges for wood gates, hinges for fence gates and types of electric fence.