Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Pick Mattock vs Cutter Mattock: Which One Should You Buy?

Pick mattock vs cutter mattock: the pick end breaks hard ground, the cutter blade slices roots and turf, and the 4 mattocks below show which suits each job.

Pick Mattock vs Cutter Mattock: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1HEIHAK 15 Inch Pick Mattock HoeHEIHAK 15 Inch Pick Mattock Hoe9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Kings County Tools Cutter Mattock with Wood HandleKings County Tools Cutter Mattock with Wood Handle9.4/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Cutter Mattock with Forged Steel Blades and 36-InchCutter Mattock with Forged Steel Blades and 36-Inch9.3/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Haliaeetus Pick AxeHaliaeetus Pick AxeView on Amazon
  5. 5NAUKII 36 Inch Pick MattockNAUKII 36 Inch Pick MattockView on Amazon
  6. 6Estwing 5-Pound Pick Mattock with 36-Inch Fiberglass HandleEstwing 5-Pound Pick Mattock with 36-Inch Fiberglass HandleView on Amazon
  7. 7Estwing 2.5-Pound Pick Mattock with 36-Inch Fiberglass HandleEstwing 2.5-Pound Pick Mattock with 36-Inch Fiberglass HandleView on Amazon
  8. 8glorousamc Forged Adze Pickglorousamc Forged Adze PickView on Amazon
  9. 9Forged Adze PickForged Adze PickView on Amazon

Pick mattock vs cutter mattock comes down to the working end: a pick mattock combines a pointed pick with an adze or hoe for breaking hard ground, while a cutter mattock combines a wide cutting blade with a pick for slicing roots and turf. The mattocks below show a pick side and a cutter side: the NAUKII and the Estwing are pick mattocks with long fiberglass handles, the CRKT Chogan is the cutter-side example with an axe blade, and the TAICHEUT is a small pick mattock for light work. This guide compares them on head shape, handle, materials and stated warranty, using only what each listing publishes.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Pick mattock vs cutter mattock: the short answer

Start with the job, then pick the shape. A pick mattock suits breaking hard ground, prying rocks and trenching: the NAUKII pick side breaks hard soil, cuts through roots and pries rocks, and the Estwing pick end drives through hard surfaces. A cutter mattock suits slicing roots and turf with a wide blade: the CRKT Chogan pairs a 2.14-inch axe blade with a spike for penetration. For a full-size tool, the NAUKII and the Estwing carry 36-inch handles; for a small tool that packs into a toolbox or backpack, the TAICHEUT measures 12 x 7.6 x 1.37 inch and the CRKT measures 19.0 x 11.5 x 2.136 inches.

The comparison table below puts the 4 mattocks side by side in ranking order, pick side against cutter side.

Pick and cutter shapes compared

Mattock Side Head Handle Warranty
NAUKII 36 Inch Pick Mattock Pick Pick and adze, rail steel 36-inch fiberglass 2 years
CRKT Chogan Mattock Cutter Axe blade and spike, 1055 carbon steel Tennessee hickory 2 years
Estwing 5-Pound Pick Mattock Pick Pick and mattock, drop-forged steel 36-inch fiberglass Not stated
TAICHEUT Weeding Mattock Hoe Pick Pointed and blunt heads, carbon steel Rubberized non-slip Not stated

These are maker ratings taken from the goat gear listings on 14 November 2026, not our own measurements.

Pick mattocks

A pick mattock pairs a pointed pick with an adze or hoe. The NAUKII lists a 2-in-1 pick and adze hoe: the pick side breaks hard soil, cuts through roots and pries rocks, while the adze side weeds, trenches and levels ground. The Estwing lists a pick end for driving through hard surfaces and a mattock end for use as a hoe in tough soil, with a drop-forged head that is heat treated and tempered. The TAICHEUT lists a dual head design with a sharp tip for breaking rocks and stones and a blunt head for leveling and compacting softer or loose soil. Each lists a pointed end for breaking ground and a flat end for moving soil.

Cutter mattocks

A cutter mattock swaps the pointed pick for a wide cutting blade. The CRKT Chogan lists a 2.14-inch axe blade in 1055 carbon steel and a spike for penetration tasks, with an adze blade for scraping and cutting. The black coating improves corrosion resistance, and the Tennessee hickory handle is burnt to add dark textures. The Chogan is the only cutter-side mattock in this guide, and it is also the smallest of the 4: 19.0 x 11.5 x 2.136 inches against 35.83 x 20.47 x 2.36 inches on the NAUKII.

Reading head weight and handle length

Head weight sets how hard each swing hits. The NAUKII head is 2kg (4.4lb) of rail steel, and the Estwing head is 5-pound drop-forged steel. The TAICHEUT is listed at 30oz, and the CRKT lists no head weight, so compare them on length instead of weight. Handle length sets leverage: the NAUKII and the Estwing carry 36-inch fiberglass handles, while the TAICHEUT measures 12 x 7.6 x 1.37 inch and the CRKT measures 19.0 x 11.5 x 2.136 inches. A longer handle gives more leverage and less bending over, which the NAUKII listing states outright.

For rocky ground, weight matters more than length: the Estwing 5-pound head and the NAUKII 2kg (4.4lb) head are the heavy hitters here, while the TAICHEUT 30oz tool suits light weeding and loosening soil. For rocky ground, see the best post hole digger for rocky soil picks. For a full day of digging, the NAUKII maker says the head is heavy enough to break tough clay and rocky ground, yet light enough to swing all day without exhausting your arms.

Materials: rail steel, drop-forged steel and carbon steel

Head material sets wear resistance. The NAUKII head is made from recycled railroad track steel, which the maker calls out for extreme wear resistance and impact toughness. The Estwing head is drop-forged steel, heat treated and tempered for strength and durability. The CRKT head is 1055 carbon steel, which the maker says provides durability and edge retention, with a black coating for corrosion resistance. The TAICHEUT heads are carbon steel, described as strong and wear-resistant.

Handles differ as much as heads. The NAUKII and the Estwing use fiberglass: the NAUKII adds a textured non-slip grip, and the Estwing uses a double-injected fiberglass handle. The CRKT uses Tennessee hickory, a dense material the maker says withstands hard use, burnt to add dark textures. The TAICHEUT uses a rubberized non-slip handle with a textured surface for grip and friction. The NAUKII grip stays comfortable even with sweaty or wet hands, per the maker.

Assembly, replacement heads and warranty

The NAUKII ships in two pieces to protect the handle during transit, and assembly is a 30-second job: tap the handle into the head until snug. The maker says the tool is ready to use in under a minute. The Estwing takes the other approach to a long tool life: replacement heads are available separately, so a worn head can be swapped without buying an entirely new mattock. The CRKT and the TAICHEUT list no assembly step and no replacement heads.

The NAUKII carries a 2-year warranty: if the mattock breaks, chips or fails under normal use within 2 years, the maker sends a replacement. The CRKT carries a 2 year manufacturer warranty. The Estwing and the TAICHEUT state no warranty term.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers mattock hardware only: head shapes, handles, materials and stated warranties. It does not cover digging technique, ground conditions beyond what the listings state, or other barn tools. For fence work, see the types of post hole diggers guide.

FAQs from goat keepers

What is a mattock pick?

A mattock pick is the pointed end of a pick mattock. On the NAUKII it breaks hard soil, cuts through roots and pries rocks, and on the Estwing it drives through hard surfaces. The pointed end pairs with an adze or hoe on the other side of the head.

What is the difference between a pick mattock and a cutter mattock?

A pick mattock combines a pointed pick with an adze or hoe for breaking hard ground. A cutter mattock combines a wide cutting blade with a pick for slicing roots and turf. In this guide the NAUKII, the Estwing and the TAICHEUT are pick mattocks, and the CRKT Chogan is the cutter-side mattock with a 2.14-inch axe blade.

Which mattock is better for rocky soil?

For rocky soil, the heavy heads lead: the Estwing carries a 5-pound drop-forged head and the NAUKII a 2kg (4.4lb) rail steel head, with 36-inch handles on each. The TAICHEUT 30oz tool suits light weeding and loosening soil rather than rock.

How long is a pick mattock handle?

The full-size pick mattocks in this guide carry 36-inch handles: the NAUKII and the Estwing list 36-inch fiberglass handles. The TAICHEUT measures 12 x 7.6 x 1.37 inch overall, and the CRKT measures 19.0 x 11.5 x 2.136 inches overall.

Does a mattock need assembly?

The NAUKII ships in two pieces and assembles in 30 seconds: tap the handle into the head until snug. The Estwing, the CRKT and the TAICHEUT list no assembly step.

More from the barn

See every barn equipment guide and all barn and farm tools guides.

More picks: best post hole digger for rocky soil, manure fork vs shovel, digging bar weight and types of post hole diggers.