
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
XtremepowerUS 1500W Electric Post Hole Digger Earth Auger DigView on Amazon - 2
VEVOR Post Hole DiggerView on Amazon - 3
72CC Gas Powered Post Hole Digger with 3 AugerView on Amazon - 4
72CC Gas Powered Post Hole Digger with 2 Drill BitsView on Amazon - 5
72CC Post Hole Digger Gas PoweredView on Amazon - 6
Baotree 72cc Gas Powered Post Hole Digger Earth AugerView on Amazon
A goat leans on a fence post, the post shifts in soft ground, and the fence line sags by morning. The fix starts before the post goes in, with a hole that fits the post and holds firm after the soil is packed back around it. This guide explains types of post hole diggers in plain terms, from the manual clamshell digger that suits a short run of posts to powered augers that suit long fence lines and hard ground.
Also worth comparing
XtremepowerUS 1500W Electric Post Hole Digger Earth Auger DigCheck price on Amazon
VEVOR Post Hole DiggerCheck price on Amazon
72CC Gas Powered Post Hole Digger with 3 AugerCheck price on Amazon
72CC Gas Powered Post Hole Digger with 2 Drill BitsCheck price on Amazon
72CC Post Hole Digger Gas PoweredCheck price on Amazon
Baotree 72cc Gas Powered Post Hole Digger Earth AugerCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Types of post hole diggers: the short answer
Start with the fence line, then match the tool to the ground. A manual clamshell digger suits a short run of posts in soft, stone free soil where the work is light and the holes are few. A manual auger suits the same kind of ground when the soil is loose and the hole needs a clean, round shape. A gas powered auger suits long fence lines, hard ground and roots, where muscle power alone turns slow. A battery powered auger offers motor power with no fuel to mix, and it suits firm ground free of heavy rock.
If the choice comes down to a powered auger or a manual tool, post hole digger vs auger sets out the trade offs, and battery vs gas post hole digger covers the powered options side by side.
Post hole digger types compared
The table below sets out the main styles side by side. Power source shapes the work most, since it decides how much effort each hole takes.
| Type | How it works | Power source | Suits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manual clamshell digger | Hinged blades close around soil and lift it out | Muscle power | Short runs in soft soil |
| Manual auger | Spiral blade twists into the ground and lifts soil as it turns | Muscle power | Loose soil and clean round holes |
| Gas powered auger | Engine turns the auger and cuts through hard ground | Gas engine | Long fence lines and hard ground |
| Battery powered auger | Motor turns the auger from a rechargeable pack | Battery pack | Firm ground and medium length fence lines |
Manual clamshell diggers
The clamshell digger is the plain hand tool most fence builders reach for, simple, quiet and easy to carry along a fence line. Long handles join at a hinge above blades that open and close like a scoop, and the blades bite into the soil, close around a scoop of earth, and lift it clear.
Clamshell diggers suit soft loam and sandy ground where the blades slide in with ease. They struggle in heavy clay when the ground is dry, in ground packed with roots, and in stony soil where the blades meet rock, and they leave no fuel, no cord and no charge to manage.
Manual augers
A manual auger is a spiral blade on a long shaft with a crossbar handle at the top. The blade twists down into the ground, and the spiral lifts soil up and out as it turns, cutting a round hole with straight sides for a neat fit.
The tool works well in loose and loamy soil, and it handles damp ground with ease. It turns slow in heavy clay and can bind on roots and stones, so loosening the top layer with a spade helps before the auger goes in. For a short fence run in kind soil, it is a calm and simple way to dig, with no engine to start and no pack to charge.
Gas powered augers
A gas powered auger pairs an engine with a spiral bit, and the engine does the turning while the operator guides the bit and holds it steady. The power cuts through hard ground, dry clay and rooty soil that would wear out arms on a manual tool, and it keeps a steady pace along a long fence line.
Gas augers are the heavy option among these styles, and the weight shows in handling, since the operator lifts the tool from hole to hole and steadies it while the bit bites. Noise and fumes come with the engine, so hearing protection and fresh air matter while the tool runs.
Battery powered augers
A battery powered auger uses a motor and a rechargeable pack to turn the bit, which gives powered digging without fuel, fumes or a pull cord. The tool starts with a switch, runs quiet beside the house and the barn, and suits firm ground free of the heavy rock and thick roots that call for a gas engine.
The pack sets the working time, so a spare pack kept charged extends the day. Battery augers suit keepers who want powered digging for a fair stretch of fence without storing fuel or caring for an engine, and the quiet running is a kindness near goats that startle at engine noise.
Matching the digger to the soil
Soil decides the tool more than brand or style, since the same auger that spins through loam can stall in clay. Soft loam and sandy ground suit every style here. Damp clay cuts easier than dry clay, so timing the work after rain can ease the digging, while ground baked hard by sun calls for a powered auger.
A clamshell digger can work around a small stone by lifting it clear, while an auger bit can catch on a root and twist in the hands. Walk the fence line before digging and probe the ground with a spade at each post mark, since a line that crosses soft ground and hard ground may need a manual tool for part of the run and a powered tool for the rest.
Hole size and depth for fence posts
The hole should be wider than the post on every side, with room for concrete or packed soil around it, and deep enough for the post to stand firm when goats lean on the fence. An auger that matches the post width gives a neat hole, while an auger wider than needed leaves a gap that takes more backfill and can leave the post loose.
Depth matters more than width for a post that must stay upright. Dig past the soft topsoil into firm ground, and set the post so the buried part grips the soil along its length. In cold country, check the frost depth for the area with the local extension office, and a guide on how to set a fence post in concrete covers the setting that follows the digging.
Power, weight and handling
Power, weight and handling trade against each other, and the right balance depends on the fence line. Manual tools are light, quiet and simple, but they ask the most from arms and back. Battery tools add motor power with modest weight, and gas tools bring the most power for hard ground and long lines, along with the most weight, noise and upkeep.
Handling deserves the same attention as power. Long handles give leverage on a manual digger, and a steady grip matters when a bit catches. Check the stated weight and the stated auger width on the listing, since those figures shape how the tool feels in use.
Reading a listing before buying
Listings vary in what they state, and the gaps matter as much as the figures. Check that the listing states the auger width, the power source, the handle style and the material of the blades or bit, and treat a missing figure as Not stated rather than guessing it from a similar tool. Where the title and the spec table disagree, trust the title and the bullets, and measure the tool on arrival before digging the fence line.
Watch for vague claims as well. A listing that calls a tool heavy duty without naming the material or the thickness gives little to judge by, and a claim about easy digging means little without a stated auger width and power source to back it. Pick the tool whose stated points match the soil and the fence line, not the tool with the loudest claims.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers digger hardware only. It does not cover fence wire, post spacing, concrete mixes or any question about goat care. Ask the local extension office about soil and frost depth for the area, and see a fencing guide for the wire and the posts that follow the digging.
FAQs from goat keepers
Which type of post hole digger suits a goat fence?
It depends on the fence line and the ground. A manual clamshell digger suits a short run in soft soil, a manual auger suits loose soil where a clean round hole helps, and a powered auger suits a long line or hard ground.
Can a manual digger handle clay soil?
A manual digger can handle clay when the ground is damp and the top layer is loosened before digging, but dry clay and heavy roots call for a powered auger. Work the soil when it yields to a spade, and clear stones from the spot before digging.
How wide should a post hole be?
The hole should be wider than the post on every side, with room for concrete or packed soil around it. Match the auger to the post width, and avoid an auger far wider than the post, since the gap takes more backfill and can leave the post loose.
What needs checking on a listing before buying?
Check that the listing states the auger width, the power source, the handle style and the blade or bit material, and treat any missing figure as Not stated. Where the title and the spec table disagree, trust the title and the bullets.
More from the barn
See how to set a fence post in concrete for the setting that follows the digging, and post hole digger vs auger for the manual and powered choice.
More picks: battery vs gas post hole diggers, how to use a post driver, fence post driver vs auger and t post vs wood post.
