Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Spring vs Hydraulic Gate Closer: Which One Should You Buy?

Spring vs hydraulic gate closer: how each type shuts a gate, and four spring closers ranked on what their listings state.

Spring vs Hydraulic Gate Closer: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Quality Life Spring Loaded Gate Latch PinQuality Life Spring Loaded Gate Latch Pin9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Gate Shut Heavy Duty Flat Gate CloserGate Shut Heavy Duty Flat Gate Closer9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3National Hardware 11-Inch Door and Gate Spring CloserNational Hardware 11-Inch Door and Gate Spring Closer9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 42 Pack 14" Fence gate Spring self Closing and Adjustable for2 Pack 14" Fence gate Spring self Closing and Adjustable forView on Amazon
  5. 5National Hardware Door and Gate SpringNational Hardware Door and Gate SpringView on Amazon
  6. 6Hardware Essentials 851838 Stainless Steel Self-Closing GateHardware Essentials 851838 Stainless Steel Self-Closing GateView on Amazon
  7. 711 Inch Gate Spring11 Inch Gate SpringView on Amazon
  8. 814 Inch Gate Spring14 Inch Gate SpringView on Amazon
  9. 914" Gate Spring Self Closing14" Gate Spring Self ClosingView on Amazon

A goat that learns the gate swings free will push through it daily, so the closer you hang matters as much as the latch. In the spring vs hydraulic gate closer question, a spring closer pulls the gate shut with a coil spring, while a hydraulic closer slows the swing with fluid so the gate eases shut instead of slamming. For a light pasture or pen gate that simply needs to stay shut, a spring closer does the job; pick hydraulic when you want the closing speed itself controlled.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Spring vs hydraulic gate closer: the short answer

Choose a spring closer for a simple self-closing gate: a coil pulls the gate shut every time, and three of the listings here let you adjust the tension with pins and a rod. Choose a hydraulic closer when the gate is heavy or you want the last part of the swing slowed so it does not slam. The four closers in the gear section below are all spring types, ranked on what their listings state; none of the four listings is a hydraulic closer.

How the two types differ

Type How it closes Adjustment Fit notes
Spring A coil spring pulls the gate shut Tension pins and adjustment rods on the Dreamxiang, BOODVON and EVCUHASL listings Match the frame and post sizes on the listing
Hydraulic Fluid inside slows the swing so the gate eases shut Not covered by these listings None of the four listings is a hydraulic closer

The gear: four spring closers, ranked

Ranked on stated adjustability, stated materials, what the box includes and how wide the fit is. All four mount with screws, and none of the four listings states a warranty term.

1. Dreamxiang 11-1/2 inch spring closer, 2 pack

The Dreamxiang listing states an 11-1/2 inch self-closing spring in carbon steel with a black powder coat, rated by the maker as anti-corrosion and rust resistant for outdoor use. Tension adjusts through locating pins and an adjustment tool, and the listing says it suits left and right side swing doors. The stated uses run long: outdoor vinyl gates, farm fences, garden fences, sheds, lawns, orchards, decks and pools. It mounts with screws, and the listing notes to install it with the locating pin facing the outside of the door.

The package list names one closer, one set of tension pins, one adjustment rod and 4 screws, while the title and the spec table say 2 pack and 2 items, so confirm the count before ordering. The listing states a 0.65 kg item weight.

2. BOODVON 14 inch spring closer, 1 pack

The BOODVON listing states a 14 inch gate spring in steel with a black powder coating, anti-corrosion and anti-rust for outdoor use. Tension adjusts with a tension pin and an adjustment rod, both included, and the listing says the post and the gate door need to be aligned, with the tension pin on the outward side of the spring. Stated uses include vinyl fence gates, metal gates, wooden fences, agricultural fences, garden fences, sheds, lawns, orchards and pools. The box lists 1 spring, 2 tension pins, 1 adjustment rod and 4 screws, and the listing states a 14.4 ounce item weight.

One listing wrinkle: the spec table lists the size as 11-1/2 inch while the title and the stated dimensions say 14 inches, so trust the title here and measure for a 14 inch spring.

3. EVCUHASL 11-1/2 inch spring closer, 1 pack

The EVCUHASL listing states an 11-1/2 inch gate spring in steel with a black powder coat, anti-corrosion and anti-rust, with adjustable tension through a tension pin and an adjustment rod. Like the BOODVON, the listing says the post and gate door need to be aligned and the tension pin goes on the outward side. Stated uses cover vinyl fence gates, metal gates, wooden fences and agricultural fences. The box lists 1 spring, 2 tension pins, 1 adjustment rod and 4 screws, and the listing states an 8 ounce item weight. It ranks below the BOODVON on the shorter stated length.

4. Jake Sales aluminum gate spring closer

The Jake Sales listing states a rust-proof aluminum gate spring closer that closes the gate automatically in either direction. It is the only one of the four made of aluminum, and the only one that states it fits a single size: a 1-3/8 inch gate frame and a 2-3/8 inch post, and the listing warns it will not fit other sizes. The listing states screw-in installation and a 0.44 kg item weight, and names residential chain link gates as the recommended use. It ranks last here on the narrow stated fit, even though the either-direction closing and aluminum build are genuine pluses.

Sizing and mounting

Mounting is screw-in on all four listings, so the main sizing job is matching the closer to the gate. The Jake Sales closer only fits a 1-3/8 inch frame and a 2-3/8 inch post, so measure both before ordering. The other three are bar-style springs that mount between the post and the gate: install one side on the post and the other on the gate, keep the two aligned, and put the tension pin on the outward side. Then set the tension with the pins and rod until the gate closes on its own without slamming.

Think about the gate itself too. A spring closer suits a light gate that just needs to stay shut; the listings name uses from garden fences and sheds to farm fences and pools. If the gate is heavy or the wind catches it, that is the case for looking at a hydraulic closer instead, which none of these four listings is.

Read the listing twice

Gate closer listings contradict themselves on the numbers you need for the install:

  • BOODVON: 14 inches in the title and the stated dimensions against 11-1/2 inches in the spec table.
  • Dreamxiang: 2 pack in the title and 2 items in the spec table against a package list that names one closer.

Measure for the larger figure where a size conflicts, and confirm the pack count with the maker before ordering. None of the four listings states a warranty term, so there is no stated coverage to fall back on.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers closer hardware only. It does not cover building the gate, choosing hinges or latches, or any veterinary question. For the latch side of the job, see our best automatic gate latch roundup.

FAQs from goat keepers

Will a spring closer slam the gate?

It can if the tension is set high. The Dreamxiang, BOODVON and EVCUHASL listings all state adjustable tension through pins and a rod, so you set the pull until the gate closes on its own. A hydraulic closer slows the swing with fluid instead, which is the type to look at if slamming is the problem.

How do I know if the Jake Sales closer fits my gate?

Measure the gate frame and the post. The listing states it only fits a 1-3/8 inch frame and a 2-3/8 inch post and warns it will not fit other sizes, so any other measurement means picking a different closer.

Do these closers work on gates that swing both ways?

The Jake Sales listing states its closer shuts the gate when opened in either direction, and the Dreamxiang listing says it suits left and right side swing doors. The BOODVON and EVCUHASL listings say the post and the gate door need to be aligned for the spring to work.

What comes in the box?

The BOODVON and EVCUHASL listings each state 1 spring, 2 tension pins, 1 adjustment rod and 4 screws with instructions. The Dreamxiang package list names a closer, tension pins, an adjustment rod and 4 screws, though its title and spec table say 2 pack, so confirm the count before ordering.

More from the barn

See every goat fencing guide and all fencing and shelter guides.

More picks: automatic gate latches, hinges for metal gates and goat gate openers.