Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Spring vs Weight Cheese Press: Which One Should You Buy?

Spring vs weight cheese presses for goat cheese compared on pressure control, setup and daily use, with listing figures cited where stated.

Spring vs Weight Cheese Press: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1EJWOX Stainless Steel Manual Press with Filter BagEJWOX Stainless Steel Manual Press with Filter Bag9.5/10View on Amazon
  2. 2PetriStor Dutch Wooden Cheese Press with Lever and 2 CheesePetriStor Dutch Wooden Cheese Press with Lever and 2 Cheese9.5/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Wooden Cheese Press for Cheese Making Supplies Diameter 11 inWooden Cheese Press for Cheese Making Supplies Diameter 11 inView on Amazon
  4. 4Wooden cheese press diameter 11.2 in and 1 cheese making formWooden cheese press diameter 11.2 in and 1 cheese making formView on Amazon
  5. 5Wooden Cheese Press for Cheese Making Supplies 16in MetalWooden Cheese Press for Cheese Making Supplies 16in MetalView on Amazon

Morning milking is done, the curds are in the mold, and now comes the question every new cheese maker asks: how do you press them? In the spring vs weight cheese press debate, the short answer is that a spring press uses a spring, often with a screw or dial, to apply steady adjustable pressure in a compact frame, while a weight press stacks weights directly on the cheese or hangs them from a lever. This guide walks through how each one works, what the listings state for pressure and size, and which suits your cheese.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Spring vs weight cheese press: the short answer

A spring cheese press pushes on the cheese with a compressed spring, usually tightened by a screw, dial or butterfly nuts, so the pressure stays constant as the curd settles. A weight press sets weights directly on the follower or hangs them from a lever arm, using gravity instead of a spring. Pick the spring press for countertop batches and fine pressure control, and the weight press for simple, heavy pressing of hard cheeses.

What a spring cheese press is

A spring press trades bulk for adjustability. The TOFUDEE listing describes a spring-and-screw design with a twist dial for setting pressure, in a 6.69 x 5.71 x 5.63 inch unit at 1.4 pounds with BPA-free food-contact parts, dishwasher safe, backed by a 1-year limited warranty. The BOONEVE listing gives a wooden and steel spring press rated up to 210 lb of pressure, adjusted with butterfly nuts, at 14.57 x 5.55 x 2.76 inches. The PetriStor spring kit is a 16 inch wooden press with two 0.48 gallon molds (5.5 inch diameter, 4.3 inch height) that includes springs and a measuring scale for setting pressure. The spring keeps pushing as the curd shrinks, so you adjust less often.

What a weight cheese press is

A weight press is gravity doing the work. The PetriStor wooden press listing gives an 11.2 inch round press with 8 inch metal guides rated for pressure up to 50 pounds, with a 45 oz cheese mold. The PetriStor Dutch press uses a lever with notches to hang weights from, rated up to 400 pounds of piston pressure, with two 6.2 inch molds. The Grand Way mold listing describes a 1.5 L mold built to sustain cheese press weights, for use under whatever weights you own. No springs to wear out, and the pressure is whatever you stack.

Pressure control compared

Spring presses win on fine control: the TOFUDEE dial and the BOONEVE butterfly nuts let you raise pressure gradually, and the PetriStor kit includes a measuring scale so you can set a number and repeat it. Weight presses win on simplicity and top end: the Dutch press reaches 400 pounds by hanging weights on lever notches, far beyond the 50 pounds of the direct wooden press. For soft and semi-hard cheeses the spring’s adjustability matters more; for hard cheeses that need heavy pressing, weight is the straightforward path. See our cheese making kit vs cheese press guide for the wider setup.

Which one should you buy

Buy a spring press if you make cheese on the counter in small batches and want to dial pressure up gradually. Buy a weight press if you press hard cheeses that need serious weight, or you prefer a tool with nothing to wear out. If you can only buy one, the spring press suits most home cheese makers starting out; add a weight or lever press when hard cheeses become the habit. For the mold side, see our best cheese press for gouda and best cheese mold for camembert guides.

FAQs from goat keepers

How much pressure does cheese need?

The listings span a wide range: up to 50 pounds for the PetriStor wooden direct press, up to 210 pounds for the BOONEVE spring press, and up to 400 pounds for the PetriStor Dutch lever press. Match the press to the cheese style you make most.

What is the measuring scale for?

The PetriStor spring kit includes a measuring scale with its springs, so you can set a specific pressure and repeat it batch after batch instead of guessing.

Do I need cheesecloth with a press?

The Grand Way kit includes a 39 x 36 inch cotton cheesecloth with its mold, while the TOFUDEE press uses cheesecloth that is not included. See our best cheesecloth for straining whey guide.

Can one press handle soft and hard cheese?

A spring press adjusts across a range with its dial or nuts, which suits varied styles. A weight press handles the range by adding or removing weights, with the Dutch lever reaching the heavy end.

More from the barn

See every cheese making kits guide and all milking guides. Also see our cheese making kit vs cheese press. Also see our best cheese press for gouda. Also see our best cheese mold for camembert.

More picks: cheesecloth for straining whey.