
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
SAEHAEYEE Stainless Steel Screw Press with Drip Tray and9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
PetriStor 602 Wooden Cheese Press with Metal Guides and Two9.4/10View on Amazon - 3
PetriStor Dutch Wooden Cheese Press with Lever and Cheese9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Wooden cheese press diameter 11.2 in and 1 cheese making formView on Amazon
The screw vs spring cheese press question comes down to control versus constancy: choose a screw press when you want high, steady pressure that you control turn by turn; choose a spring press when you want pressure that keeps itself constant as the curd shrinks, though no spring-type press is listed here. The four listings below are all manual presses: the EJWOX 3.69-gallon uses a heavy-duty T-handle Acme screw, the SQUEEZE master uses a ball handle, the EJWOX 1.6-gallon uses a top handle, and the Fante’s is a cookie press for dough, not a cheese press. This guide compares the screw-side listings and flags what the missing spring side would add.
Also worth comparing
Wooden cheese press diameter 11.2 in and 1 cheese making formCheck price on Amazon
Wooden Cheese Press for Cheese Making Supplies 16in MetalCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Screw vs spring cheese press: the short answer
A screw press builds pressure mechanically and holds it where you set it; the EJWOX 3.69-gallon listing says its T-handle turns a large-diameter Acme screw to create high pressure with little effort. A spring press would trade that control for automatic follow-up as whey leaves the curd, but none of the listings here describes a spring mechanism, so we cannot compare one directly. If you press firm, long-aged goat cheese and want to set the pressure and walk away, the listings here only cover the screw side. For the wood-versus-metal version of this question, see our wood vs metal cheese press guide.
The screw side, from the listings
Two listings are clearly screw-type. The EJWOX 3.69-gallon is a thread-type device with a food-grade stainless pressing basket, a powder-coated frame and stand, and a basket the listing says detaches from the plate for cleanup. The SQUEEZE master is a 0.8-gallon, 3-litre press with a ball handle in stainless steel and iron, listed for cheese among fruit, wine and olive oil, and quiet at about 35 dB. The EJWOX 1.6-gallon is a top-handle manual press with a filter bag, listed for cheese and honey; the listing does not name its mechanism, so we do not call it a screw press.
The spring side, and what is missing
None of the four listings describes a spring mechanism, so the spring side of this comparison has no listed example. A spring press holds pressure automatically as the curd shrinks, which the screw listings here cannot do without another turn of the handle. If you want that feature, check the listing text for the word spring before buying; these four do not state it. The Fante’s listing is a cookie press that extrudes dough into shapes, so it is not a cheese press of either type.
Capacity against your batch
The EJWOX 3.69-gallon basket holds up to 14 litres, the most here, for large harvest batches. The EJWOX 1.6-gallon holds 6 litres for moderate batches, and the SQUEEZE master holds 3 litres for small ones. The Fante’s is sized for dough at 9.5 by 2.5 by 2.5 inches, not curd. Match the basket to your typical milk run; a half-full big press wastes effort. Compare press styles in our wood vs plastic cheese press guide.
Materials and cleanup
Stainless baskets clean well: the EJWOX 3.69-gallon basket detaches from the plate, and the SQUEEZE master lists stainless steel throughout. The EJWOX 1.6-gallon includes a filter bag, which catches pulp before it reaches the works. The Fante’s disassembles for hand washing in warm, soapy water. Rinse dairy equipment right after pressing; dried curd is hard to remove from any mechanism.
What this guide does not cover
It does not cover spring presses, since none is listed. It does not cover hydraulic presses or cheese molds; see our silicone vs plastic cheese mold guide for molds. It does not cover pressing times or weights, which the listings do not state.
FAQs from goat keepers
Is a screw press better than a spring press?
A screw press gives controlled, high pressure per turn; a spring press holds pressure as the curd shrinks. The listings here only show screw-type presses, so the comparison rests on the screw side.
Can these presses press cheese?
The SQUEEZE master and EJWOX 1.6-gallon listings name cheese among their uses. The EJWOX 3.69-gallon is listed for fruit, herbs, nut milks and honey. The Fante’s is a cookie press for dough.
What capacity do I need for goat cheese?
Listed capacities here run from 3 litres to 14 litres. Match the basket to your batch; the 3.69-gallon EJWOX suits large harvest batches.
Are these dishwasher safe?
The listings do not state dishwasher safety. The Fante’s says hand wash; rinse the stainless presses right after use.
More from the barn
See every cheese making kits guide and all goat milking guides.
More picks: wood vs metal cheese press, wood vs plastic cheese press and bleached vs unbleached cheesecloth.
