Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Wood vs Plastic Cheese Press: Which One Should You Buy?

Compare wood and plastic cheese presses: stated pressure, mold sizes, materials and cleaning, with figures taken from the listings.

Wood vs Plastic Cheese Press: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1PandaHall Wood Soap BevelerPandaHall Wood Soap Beveler9.5/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Wadoy 2-Pack Plastic Tofu Press Mold with Cheese ClothWadoy 2-Pack Plastic Tofu Press Mold with Cheese Cloth9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3BOONEVE CHPR1 Wooden Cheese Press with Spring MechanismBOONEVE CHPR1 Wooden Cheese Press with Spring Mechanism9.6/10View on Amazon

The curds are drained, the mold is filled, and now the wheel needs steady pressure for hours: this is where the wood vs plastic cheese press question matters. The short answer is that wooden presses list higher stated pressure, up to 50 pounds on the PetriStor listings, while plastic molds trade pressure for easy cleaning and smaller batches. This guide compares the two on stated pressure, mold size, materials and care, using only figures from the listings.

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

The wood vs plastic cheese press question, answered

Start with what you make. A wooden press suits hard and semi-hard cheeses that need long, firm pressing: the PetriStor wooden presses list pressure up to 50 pounds with 45 oz cheese forms and 11.2 in diameters. A plastic mold kit suits soft and semi-soft cheeses and small batches: the Grand Way kit lists a 1.5 L food grade polypropylene mold with a 39 by 36 in cotton cheesecloth. If you would rather go straight to the products, our best cheese press under 75 roundup scores five presses on these points.

Wooden presses: stated pressure and sizes

Wooden presses press with weight or springs on a frame. The PetriStor listings state pressure up to 50 pounds on models with an 11.2 in diameter, 8 in metal guides and 45 oz cheese forms. A larger model lists 16 in wooden guides, 2 molds of 1.3 qt each and dimensions of 15,7 x 7,8 x 7.5 in. The spring model lists a 16 in plywood frame, 1/2 in thick, with 2 molds of 0.48 gal (5.5 in diameter, 4.3 in height), plus springs and a measuring scale, at 15.9 by 7.9 by 6.6 in and 6.98 lbs.

The molds on these wooden presses are food grade hard polypropylene with a follower piston, per the PetriStor listings, so the wood is the frame and the food contact surface is plastic. Wood needs more care than plastic: keep the frame dry between uses and check the guides stay straight.

Plastic molds and kits

Plastic kits skip the frame and press by hand or with light weights. The Grand Way kit lists a 1.5 L food grade polypropylene mold with a press follower and a 39 by 36 in 100% cotton cheesecloth, washable and reusable, at 5.9 by 5.9 by 2.76 in and 6.4 oz. The listing says the set suits soft, semi-soft, semi-hard and hard cheeses. The mold is dishwasher safe and the cheesecloth is hand wash. For a stainless option, the Crommie paneer maker lists 350 ml of food grade stainless steel at 5 by 5 by 2 in.

Press Stated pressure Mold Frame
PetriStor wooden, 11.2 in Up to 50 pounds 45 oz form, food grade polypropylene Wood, 8 in metal guides
PetriStor wooden, 16 in Up to 50 lbs 2 molds, 1.3 qt each 16 in wooden guides
PetriStor spring, 16 in Springs, scale included 2 molds, 0.48 gal 16 in plywood, 1/2 in thick
Grand Way plastic kit Not stated 1.5 L polypropylene mold None, hand press

Pressure: weight vs spring

Wooden presses apply pressure two ways: direct weight on the follower, or springs. The PetriStor spring model includes springs and a measuring scale so you can read the pressure you apply, and the plywood is listed as 12 mm thick, oil-wax coated and moisture resistant. Direct-weight models list up to 50 pounds of pressure. Our spring vs weight cheese press guide compares the two mechanisms. Plastic kits state no pressure figure, which tells you they are made for lighter pressing.

Cleaning and care

Plastic wins on cleaning: the Grand Way mold is dishwasher safe, and polypropylene does not absorb odors the way wood can. Wooden frames need hand drying and a dry store; the spring model’s oil-wax coated plywood helps with moisture. Cheesecloths wash and reuse: the Grand Way cloth is 100% cotton at 39 by 36 in. See our best cheesecloth for straining whey picks for more cloth options.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers press hardware only. It does not cover recipes, cultures, aging times or any food safety question. Follow your recipe, and for food safety questions check with your local extension office.

FAQs from goat keepers

Which press is better for hard cheese?

The wooden presses list pressure up to 50 pounds, which suits hard and semi-hard cheeses that need long, firm pressing. The plastic kits state no pressure figure.

Can I use a plastic mold for hard cheese?

The Grand Way listing says its kit suits cheeses from soft through hard, but it states no pressure figure, so expect lighter pressing than a wooden frame gives.

How do I clean a wooden cheese press?

The listings state no cleaning instructions for the wooden frames; the molds themselves are food grade polypropylene. Dry the wood fully between uses and store it dry.

What size mold do I need?

The Grand Way mold holds 1.5 L, the PetriStor forms hold 45 oz or 1.3 qt, and the spring model molds hold 0.48 gal. Match the mold to your batch size.

More from the barn

See every cheese making kit guide and all milking guides. Also see our cheese making kit vs cheese press. Also see our cheese making kit vs cheese mold.

More picks: cheese presses under 75, cheese press for gouda, spring vs weight press.