
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Rubbermaid BRUTE 50-Gallon9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
BUYYAH 11-Gallon Automatic9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Domivans 12-Gallon Stainless9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
BUYYAH 12-Gallon with Stand9.6/10View on Amazon
A goat that finds an empty bucket at dawn will climb the fence and complain until the morning milking is done, so water trough ideas that keep water in front of the herd all day are worth a careful look. This guide covers water trough ideas by type, capacity, material and the extras some troughs add, such as float valves and stands. Every figure below comes from an Amazon listing for a trough we compared, and we point out where those listings contradict themselves.
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
| # | Product | GoatGear Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Rubbermaid BRUTE 50-Gallon | 9.7/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 | BUYYAH 11-Gallon Automatic | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 | Domivans 12-Gallon Stainless | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 | BUYYAH 12-Gallon with Stand | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |

Rubbermaid BRUTE 50-Gallon
A 50 gallon structural foam stock tank, 12 inches high, for a pen or pasture that needs a large, low water source.
Pros
- 50 gallon capacity, the largest in this guide
- Structural foam with a ribbed base and body stiffeners
- Smooth surface with no sharp surfaces stated
- 10-Year Limited Warranty stated in the bullets
Cons
- No float valve or drain hole is stated, so refills and emptying are manual
- 22.0 pounds before water, so moving it takes effort
- At 52.0 inches long it needs a wide, level spot in the pen
- Spec table lists the warranty only as 'Warranty' while the bullets name the 10-year term

BUYYAH 11-Gallon Automatic
An 11 gallon automatic trough in PP plastic on a galvanized stand with 3 height levels, for goats of different heights.
Pros
- 11 gallons with a hose and 1/2 inch to 3/4 inch adapter
- 3 adjustable height levels for animals of different heights
- PP plastic trough on a galvanized metal stand
- 2 Year Manufacture warranty stated in the spec table
Cons
- Title names a float valve the bullets never describe
- Bullets describe feed capacity in a listing for water
- Gloves are needed during installation, per the listing
- Trough is PP plastic, not steel

Domivans 12-Gallon Stainless
A 12 gallon stainless steel trough with a float valve, a drain hole and a 4.75 ft braided hose, for a pen near a water line.
Pros
- Automatic float valve refills the trough as animals drink
- Stainless steel with a smooth interior and rolled edges
- Drain hole for emptying old water and cleaning
- 4.75 ft stainless steel braided hose with quick-connect fittings
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- 5.3 inch height gives a shallow pool next to a 12 inch stock tank
- Needs a compatible water line or faucet nearby
- No stand or height adjustment is stated

BUYYAH 12-Gallon with Stand
A 12 gallon plastic trough on a galvanized stand with 3 height levels and fixing devices for muddy soil, cement soil and wooden floors.
Pros
- 12 gallon capacity with room for 6 sheep to drink at once
- 3 adjustable height levels for animals of different heights
- Plastic trough on a galvanized metal stand
- Reinforcement accessories with fixing devices for muddy soil, cement soil and wooden floors
Cons
- No warranty term is stated; the spec table lists 'NO'
- Title and bullets repeat the 11 gallon listing almost word for word
- Bullets describe feed capacity in a listing for water
- No float valve or drain hole is stated
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Water trough ideas: the short answer
Start with where the trough will go, then pick the type, then check capacity and build. A stock tank suits a pen or pasture with room for a wide, low tub. An automatic trough with a float valve suits a pen near a water line or faucet. A trough on a stand with height adjustment suits goats of different heights and keeps the rim off muddy ground. Once the type is settled, compare the stated capacity and material.
If you would rather go straight to the products, our best water trough for goats under 50 roundup scores troughs on these points.
Trough types compared
| Type | Example listing | Stated capacity | Water supply | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stock tank | Rubbermaid BRUTE Stock Tank, 50-Gallon | 50 gallons | No valve stated | |
| Automatic trough | Domivans 12 Gallon Stainless Steel Automatic Trough | 12 gallons | Float valve, 4.75 ft hose | |
| Automatic trough on a stand | BUYYAH Automatic Livestock Water Trough, 11 Gallon | 11 gallons | Hose and adapter | |
| Trough on a stand | BUYYAH Livestock Water Trough with Adjustable Stand, 12 Gallon | 12 gallons | No valve stated |
Stock tanks
A stock tank is a wide, low tub. The Rubbermaid BRUTE lists structural foam, a ribbed base, body stiffeners and a 12 inch height, at 52.0 inches long, 31.0 inches wide and 22.0 pounds. The listing states weather, impact and corrosion resistance and a smooth surface with no sharp surfaces.
Automatic troughs
An automatic trough refills itself from a water line through a float valve. The Domivans lists a built-in float valve, a drain hole, rolled edges and a 4.75 ft stainless steel braided hose with quick-connect fittings, in stainless steel. The BUYYAH 11 gallon listing calls itself automatic with a float valve in the title, but the bullets describe a hose with a 1/2 inch to 3/4 inch adapter and never name a float valve.
Troughs on stands
A trough on a stand adjusts to the animals. The BUYYAH listings, 11 gallon and 12 gallon, share a galvanized metal stand with 3 adjustable height levels, low gear for chickens, ducks and geese, medium gear for lambs, and high gear for goats and horses. The 12 gallon listing adds fixing devices for muddy soil, cement soil and wooden floors.
Reading capacity against your herd
Capacity on these listings is given in gallons of water. The Rubbermaid stock tank lists 50 gallons, the Domivans lists 12 gallons, the BUYYAH 11 gallon listing lists 11 gallons and the BUYYAH 12 gallon listing lists 12 gallons. None of these listings converts gallons into a daily ration, so treat gallons as a way to rank troughs against each other, not as a daily ration.
Materials: structural foam, stainless steel or plastic
The listings we compared use these materials:
- Structural foam: the Rubbermaid stock tank, described as weather, impact and corrosion resistant by the maker.
- Stainless steel: the Domivans trough, with a smooth interior and rolled edges.
- PP plastic on a galvanized metal stand: the BUYYAH troughs, described as rust-proof by the maker.
Float valves, drain holes and hoses
A float valve keeps the water level steady without carrying buckets. The Domivans listing states a built-in float valve and a drain hole for emptying old water and cleaning, plus a 4.75 ft braided hose with quick-connect fittings. The BUYYAH 11 gallon title names a float valve, but the bullets name a hose and adapter instead, so check the listing before you buy. Our float valve vs ball valve water trough guide compares valve types. Only the Domivans listing states a drain hole.
Read the listing with care
Trough listings often contradict themselves:
- BUYYAH 11 gallon: a float valve in the title, a hose and adapter in the bullets.
- BUYYAH 11 gallon and 12 gallon: feed capacity up to 66 lbs with feed in listings for water.
- BUYYAH 12 gallon: the same 39.0 by 12.0 by 19.0 inch size as the 11 gallon listing, with a warranty field that reads “NO”.
- Rubbermaid: the spec table lists the warranty only as “Warranty” while the bullets name the 10-year limited term.
Measure your pen before ordering.
The gear we picked
The troughs below handle the jobs in this guide: holding water, refilling automatically, and sitting at the right height on a stand.
FAQs from goat keepers
What size water trough do goats need?
Capacity runs from 11 gallons on the BUYYAH automatic trough to 50 gallons on the Rubbermaid stock tank. None converts gallons to a daily ration, so compare gallons between troughs and leave room at the rim.
Are automatic water troughs good for goats?
An automatic trough with a float valve refills itself from a water line, so the pen keeps water without carrying buckets. The Domivans listing states a built-in float valve, a drain hole and a 4.75 ft braided hose.
Do water troughs come with a stand?
Some do. The BUYYAH troughs list a galvanized metal stand with 3 adjustable height levels, low gear for chickens, ducks and geese, medium gear for lambs, high gear for goats and horses. The Rubbermaid stock tank and the Domivans trough list no stand.
How do you clean a livestock water trough?
The Domivans listing states a smooth interior for rinsing and cleaning and a drain hole for emptying old water. The other listings state no drain hole.
Behind the Farm Score
The GoatGear Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For water troughs, safety means a smooth rim with no sharp surfaces and rolled edges. The Rubbermaid and BUYYAH 11 gallon listings state a warranty; the others state none. How we pick explains the weights.
More from the barn
See every water trough guide and all feeding and water guides.
More picks: best water trough for goats under 50, best hay feeders for goats, goat mineral feeders and heated water buckets.
