Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Portable vs Permanent Electric Fence: Which One Should You Buy?

Portable vs permanent electric fence: electric netting listings compared by size, strands and energizer needs, with how to choose for goats.

Portable vs Permanent Electric Fence: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1QMARK Electric Fence Gate HandlesQMARK Electric Fence Gate Handles9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2EFencSolv Electric Fence Gate KitEFencSolv Electric Fence Gate Kit9.7/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Gallagher Smart Fence 2 328ft 4-Strand Portable ElectricGallagher Smart Fence 2 328ft 4-Strand Portable Electric9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Portable Electric Fence Polywire 656 Feet 200 Meter 6Portable Electric Fence Polywire 656 Feet 200 Meter 6View on Amazon
  5. 51312 Feet Portable Electric Fence Polywire with 6 Conductors1312 Feet Portable Electric Fence Polywire with 6 ConductorsView on Amazon
  6. 6Electric Fence WireElectric Fence WireView on Amazon
  7. 7VEVOR Electric Fence WireVEVOR Electric Fence WireView on Amazon
  8. 8Electric Fence PolywireElectric Fence PolywireView on Amazon
  9. 9Portable Electric Fence Polywire 5050ft 1540m 6 Steel StrandsPortable Electric Fence Polywire 5050ft 1540m 6 Steel StrandsView on Amazon

The portable vs permanent electric fence question is about moving with the herd against setting it once: portable netting moves in minutes for rotational grazing, while a permanent fence stays put for year-round containment. For goats on pasture rotation, portable wins; for a home pen, permanent wins. This guide explains both using figures from electric fence listings.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Portable vs permanent electric fence: the short answer

Pick portable netting for rotational grazing: the Premier 1 PoultryNet Plus is 48 in high by 100 ft long with posts every 6.8 ft, and the LMRSTOO netting is 49.6 in by 164 ft at 22 pounds with 14 posts. Pick permanent for a fixed pen that must hold goats year-round. Every number below comes from one of these listings.

How portable electric netting works

Unroll, step in, energize

Portable netting arrives prefabricated with posts built in. The Premier 1 installs in less than 10 minutes from out of the box, with posts every 6.8 ft to reduce sag. The Pet and Livestock HQ netting is 41 in by 164 ft with 19 fiberglass posts every 9 ft, and the ouluu is 47.5 in by 164 ft with 14 strands, 11 conductive. Energizers are sold separately: the LMRSTOO recommends a 0.3 to 0.5 joule energizer, the LoJok a 0.5 joule unit, and the PPOLB a 0.25 joule unit.

Move it weekly

The whole point is rotation. The ouluu listing calls the netting ideal for rotational grazing, and the LoJok calls it perfect for rotational grazing and temporary fencing. At 14.77 to 23 pounds, one person can carry and reposition a roll. The PPOLB states the netting relocates without leaving a permanent structure. For charger picks, see our best electric fence charger for rotational grazing.

How a permanent electric fence works

Fixed posts, fixed wires

A permanent fence uses driven posts and tensioned wire or polytape that stays up for years. It holds its charge better in weeds and wind, and it handles larger areas without the voltage drop that long netting runs can suffer. No permanent fence listings appear in the reference data, so treat this section as general guidance rather than measured figures.

When permanent wins

Permanent wins for the home pen, the buck pen and any boundary that must hold goats every day. It wins on durability: no fabric to degrade, no posts to pull weekly. It loses on flexibility: once the posts are driven, the fence does not move with the forage. For fence picks, see our best electric fence for goats.

Netting details that matter

Strand count sets the shock and the containment. The Pet and Livestock HQ netting has 11 horizontal strands with 9 conductive, and the bottom 2 strands are not electrified to prevent shorting in weeds. The LoJok is 42.5 in by 164 ft with 11 strands, 9 conductive, and is stated as not for poultry. The PPOLB 47.5 in netting has 14 strands, 11 conductive. The PetSafe wireless dog fences in the data are for dogs, not goats, and do not apply here.

What this guide does not cover

This guide does not cover barbed wire, woven wire or high-tensile wire, which are separate fence types. It does not cover chargers or grounding in detail. For wire comparisons, see our barbed wire vs electric fence.

FAQs from goat keepers

Which is better for goats, portable or permanent electric fence?

For rotational grazing, portable netting: rolls like the LMRSTOO at 49.6 in by 164 ft move in minutes. For a fixed home pen, a permanent fence holds better year-round.

How long does portable netting take to install?

The Premier 1 PoultryNet Plus states less than 10 minutes from out of the box to installed fence. The Pet and Livestock HQ states no tools are required.

What size energizer do these nets need?

The LMRSTOO recommends 0.3 to 0.5 joule, the LoJok 0.5 joule, and the PPOLB 0.25 joule solar or AC and DC energizers. Energizers are not included with the netting.

Can goats escape through the bottom of the netting?

The Pet and Livestock HQ states the bottom 3 strands are 2 in apart so small animals cannot escape, and the bottom 2 strands are not electrified to prevent weed shorting.

Are wireless dog fences suitable for goats?

No. The PetSafe listings are dog collar systems covering up to 3/4 acre, designed for dogs 5 to 8 pounds and up. Goats need livestock netting, not pet containment collars.

More from the barn

See every fencing and shelter guide.

More picks: electric fences for goats, electric fence chargers for goats, electric netting vs barbed wire and poly wire vs woven wire fence.