Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Round vs Rectangular Stock Tank: Which One Should You Buy?

Round vs rectangular stock tank: how shape changes daily chores, capacity and placement, with concrete sizes and capacities from current listings.

Round vs Rectangular Stock Tank: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1VEVOR 8ft Stock Tank Round Pool Liner for 27.5 in Wall HeightVEVOR 8ft Stock Tank Round Pool Liner for 27.5 in Wall Height9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Behlen Country RE328 294-Gallon Galvanized Round-End TankBehlen Country RE328 294-Gallon Galvanized Round-End TankView on Amazon

Round vs rectangular stock tank comes down to the pen, not the tank: round tanks suit open pens where goats drink from all sides, and rectangular tanks suit fence lines and barn walls where the flat side sits flush. A frozen bucket on a cold morning is the yearly reminder that whatever shape you pick has to be easy to dump, scrub and refill. This guide walks through shape, capacity, footprint, materials and chores using concrete figures from current stock tank listings, and points to the site’s product guides where they help.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Round vs rectangular stock tank: the short answer

Choose round when the tank sits in the middle of a pen or pasture. Goats can drink from every side, the tank can be rolled to a new spot, and a round wall has no corners. Choose rectangular when the tank goes against a barn wall or fence line: the flat side sits flush, the footprint tucks into corners, and the tank will not roll. For specific models, see our best stock tank for goats.

How shape changes daily chores

The daily chore is dumping and scrubbing, and shape decides how it goes. A round tank tips and rolls: the 15-gallon Behrens 2GS, 22 inches across and 11 inches tall at 4.6 pounds, can be tipped on its side and rolled to the drain spot. A rectangular tank tips end over end: the 15-gallon Fortex CR850, 25.5 by 25.5 by 9.75 inches at 10.9 pounds, is heavier empty but its flat sides give a stable edge to tip from.

Scrubbing favors the shape you can reach into. The 9-gallon Laguna tub is 19.5 inches across and 9.5 inches tall, low enough to reach the bottom from any side. Taller tanks mean longer reaches: the Behrens stands 11 inches tall against the Fortex at 9.75 inches. In winter the chore becomes breaking ice, and a round opening takes a round cover: the iBirdie 8-foot cover measures 98 by 98 by 12 inches and the 6-foot cover 72 by 72 by 12 inches. See our heated vs unheated stock tank for the cold-weather decision.

Round tanks: what the listings show

The round listings here run from 9 to 15 gallons. The Laguna planting tub states 9 gallons (34 liters), 19.5 inches in diameter and 9.5 inches tall, weighing 1.9 pounds in plastic. The Behrens 2GS states 15 gallons, 22 by 22 by 11 inches and 4.6 pounds, in galvanized steel with an offset bottom that keeps the tub off the ground. The maker describes the Behrens as rodent proof and recyclable, and states the steel will not leach into food.

Round also wins on cover selection in these listings. QH.HOME lists 6-foot and 8-foot round covers, iBirdie lists 6-foot and 8-foot round covers, and Sobana lists a 7 to 8-foot round cover at 96 by 96 inches. The QH.HOME 8-foot cover uses a winch closure and the maker claims it stands up to winds over 100 miles per hour; the iBirdie covers use a drawstring plus velcro strap and state a 1 year manufacturer warranty. For the material question, see our galvanized vs plastic stock tank.

Rectangular tanks: what the listings show

The rectangular listing here is the Fortex CR850: 15 gallons, 25.5 by 25.5 by 9.75 inches, 10.9 pounds, in rubber the maker describes as crack and crush resistant and flexible to low temperatures, bouncing back to shape. The flat sides sit flush against a barn wall or fence line, and at 9.75 inches tall it is the lowest profile of the three tanks here.

The trade is cover selection. None of the cover listings here are cut for a rectangle, so a rectangular tank outdoors needs a tarp or a fitted cover bought to its own measurements. What the rectangle gives back is placement: it does not roll, it uses wall space fully, and two of them can sit side by side with no wasted gap.

Reading capacity and footprint

Compare gallons against footprint, not just the shape name. The Behrens holds 15 gallons in a 22 by 22 inch footprint; the Fortex holds the same 15 gallons in a 25.5 by 25.5 inch footprint. The Laguna holds 9 gallons in a 19.5-inch diameter. Empty weights run from 1.9 pounds on the Laguna to 10.9 pounds on the Fortex, which matters the first time you carry the tank out to the pen.

Tank Shape Capacity Footprint
Behrens 2GS Round 15 gallons 22 by 22 by 11 in
Laguna planting tub Round 9 gallons 19.5 in diameter, 9.5 in tall
Fortex CR850 Rectangular 15 gallons 25.5 by 25.5 by 9.75 in

Figures as stated in each listing. A bigger footprint is harder to move and easier to bump; a smaller one needs refilling more often.

Materials in these listings

Three materials appear: galvanized steel on the Behrens, rubber on the Fortex and plastic on the Laguna. The Behrens maker notes sealant may be visible at the seams and states that it ensures waterproofing. The Fortex rubber is the only one the maker describes as flexible to low temperatures. The Laguna plastic is the lightest at 1.9 pounds. None of the three tank listings states a concrete warranty term; the iBirdie covers state a 1 year manufacturer warranty.

What this guide does not cover

Automatic waterers, heated tanks and deicers are separate buying decisions and are covered in the related guides below. Pool liners, such as the VEVOR 8-foot and 10-foot round liners for 27.5-inch wall heights, belong to pool setups rather than stock tanks and sit outside this guide.

FAQs from goat keepers

What sizes do the round listings state?

The Behrens 2GS states 15 gallons at 22 by 22 by 11 inches, and the Laguna states 9 gallons at 19.5 inches in diameter and 9.5 inches tall. Round covers here fit 6-foot and 8-foot tanks.

What does the rectangular listing state?

The Fortex CR850 states 15 gallons, 25.5 by 25.5 by 9.75 inches and 10.9 pounds, in rubber the maker describes as crack and crush resistant.

Which shape is easier to clean?

Round tanks have no corners and can be rolled; the 9.5-inch-tall Laguna is the easiest to reach into. Rectangular tanks sit still against a wall while you scrub.

Do the cover listings fit rectangular tanks?

No. Every cover listing here is round, from 6-foot to 8-foot sizes. A rectangular tank needs a cover matched to its own footprint.

Do any of these state a warranty?

The iBirdie covers state a 1 year manufacturer warranty. The Behrens warrants against manufacturer’s defects with no term stated, and the Fortex and Laguna state no concrete term.

More from the barn

See every water trough guide and all feeding and water guides. Also see our stock tank vs trough. Also see our heated vs unheated stock tank.

More picks: stock tanks for goats, galvanized vs plastic, stock tanks for winter.