Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Shade Cloth vs Windbreak Netting: Which One Should You Buy?

Shade cloth vs windbreak netting explained by purpose, with four shade cloths compared on size, shade rate, grommets and warranty for sun and wind problems.

Shade Cloth vs Windbreak Netting: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Toriexon Electric Fence Netting 42.5 Inches High by 164 FeetToriexon Electric Fence Netting 42.5 Inches High by 164 Feet9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 260% Shade Cloth Roll 6ft x 100ft60% Shade Cloth Roll 6ft x 100ftView on Amazon
  3. 3Agfabric 70% 12X 16ft Sunblock Shade Cloth with Grommets forAgfabric 70% 12X 16ft Sunblock Shade Cloth with Grommets forView on Amazon
  4. 410x20FT Shade Cloth10x20FT Shade ClothView on Amazon
  5. 5Sun Shade Cloth with Grommets for GardenSun Shade Cloth with Grommets for GardenView on Amazon
  6. 690% White Shade Cloth90% White Shade ClothView on Amazon

Hay on the ground, a goat standing on the fence line, and a pen that bakes in the afternoon sun while the wind cuts across the yard from the other side: that pen needs two different answers, and shade cloth vs windbreak netting is the choice between them. Shade cloth is the screen for sun: it blocks sun and ultraviolet rays while letting air flow through. Windbreak netting is the screen for wind: it slows wind at the fence line. This guide compares the two screens by purpose, then covers four shade cloths from listings, with size, shade rate, grommets and warranty for each.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Shade cloth vs windbreak netting: the short answer

Pick shade cloth when the problem is sun on the pen. Every shade cloth featured below states a 90% shade or ultraviolet block, and every one states airflow through the fabric, so the pen stays shaded without turning into a closed box. Pick windbreak netting when the problem is wind across the pen, since a shade cloth is made to block sun, not to stop wind. Where sun and wind both hit the pen, hang the shade cloth for the sunny side and plan the wind screen for the windy side, rather than expecting a single screen to solve both problems.

Shade cloth and windbreak netting compared

Screen Job What the featured listings state
Shade cloth Block sun and ultraviolet rays, let air through 90% shade or ultraviolet block on all four featured cloths
Windbreak netting Slow wind at the fence line No windbreak netting pick is featured below

The table keeps the two jobs apart on purpose. A shade cloth listing talks about sun, shade rate, airflow and grommets. A windbreak netting listing would talk about wind, and none of the featured listings does. Judge each screen on its own job, and do not credit a shade cloth with wind protection that its listing never claims.

The gear: four shade cloths, in ranked order

The Coolaroo ranks first here. It states a 90% ultraviolet block, a 6 by 100 ft roll that can be cut to fit, tear, fade and fray resistant HDPE, water resistance, and a 15-year warranty against ultraviolet degradation. The roll form suits a pen of odd shape, since the cloth can be cut to the space, and the warranty term is the longest stated in this group.

The winemana ranks second. It states a 20 by 30 ft panel at a 90% shade rate, high density polyethylene, lock-stitch knitting, a taped edge with reinforced corners, and grommets on each side every 40 inches. The spec table gives 240 by 360 by 0.04 inches and an item weight of 9.02 pounds. The large ready-made panel suits a pergola, greenhouse or coop roof without cutting.

The Shade&Beyond ranks third. It states a 6 by 10 ft panel at 90% sun block, 200GSM high-density polyethylene, double grommets on each edge, grommets on each side every 2 ft, and included bungees, ropes and zip ties. The spec table gives 120 by 72 inches and an item weight of 2.9 pounds, and the listing states a 5 Year Limit Warranty. The included fixings suit a quick hang on a patio, garden or backyard frame.

The ABOSUN ranks fourth. It states a 6 by 6 ft panel at 90% ultraviolet protection, high-density polyethylene with frost and moisture resistance, water resistance, and reinforced copper grommets spaced every 1.8 ft. The spec table gives 72 by 72 inches. No warranty term is stated for this listing, which is the main gap against the three cloths above it.

Shade cloth Size stated Shade stated Grommets stated Warranty stated
Coolaroo 6 by 100 ft roll 90% ultraviolet block Not stated 15-year against ultraviolet degradation
winemana 20 by 30 ft 90% shade rate Every 40 inches Not stated
Shade&Beyond 6 by 10 ft 90% sun block Every 2 ft, double on each edge 5 Year Limit Warranty
ABOSUN 6 by 6 ft 90% ultraviolet protection Every 1.8 ft, copper Not stated

Sizes are stated in feet and inches

Titles state sizes in feet, while spec tables state sizes in inches, so read both before ordering. The Coolaroo title states a 6 by 100 ft roll and the spec table states 1200 by 72 inches. The winemana title states 20 by 30 ft and the spec table states 240 by 360 by 0.04 inches. The Shade&Beyond title states 6 by 10 ft and the spec table states 120 by 72 inches. The ABOSUN title states 6 by 6 ft and the spec table states 72 by 72 inches. Measure the pen or frame first, then match the stated size to the space, and allow for the stretch the winemana listing warns about, since it states that side length may vary with manual measurement while the area stays constant.

Which screen for which pen

For a sunny pen with no wind problem, any of the four featured cloths fits, since all four state a 90% block. For a large roof span, the winemana panel or the Coolaroo roll covers more ground with fewer joins. For a small patio or garden frame, the Shade&Beyond panel or the ABOSUN panel fits without cutting, and the Shade&Beyond adds fixings in the box. For a pen where goats lean on the fence, grommet spacing matters: the ABOSUN spaces copper grommets every 1.8 ft, the Shade&Beyond spaces grommets every 2 ft with doubles on each edge, and the winemana spaces grommets every 40 inches. For a windy pen, none of these four is the answer, since none states wind reduction: that pen needs windbreak netting on the windy side, with shade cloth kept for the sunny side.

Grommets, airflow and cleaning

Grommets decide how the cloth hangs and how long the edge lasts. The winemana lists a taped edge with reinforced corners and grommets along the entire reinforced edge. The Shade&Beyond lists double grommets on each edge and seams and stitching for durability. The ABOSUN lists heavy-duty metal grommets in copper. The Coolaroo lists no grommets and is cut to fit, so plan the fastening separately for that roll. On airflow, all four listings state breathable fabric that lets air through, and the winemana states that water drops through the fabric while hot air is pushed out. On cleaning, the winemana states that the cloth can be cleaned with a garden hose.

FAQs from goat keepers

Is shade cloth the same as windbreak netting?

No. Shade cloth blocks sun and ultraviolet rays while letting air flow through, and windbreak netting slows wind at the fence line. They solve different problems, so pick by the problem the pen actually has.

Can a single screen do both jobs?

Not on the evidence of these listings. The four featured shade cloths state shade, airflow and grommets, and none states wind reduction. A pen with both sun and wind needs shade cloth for the sunny side and windbreak netting for the windy side.

What shade rate do these cloths state?

All four state 90%: the winemana states a 90% shade rate, the Coolaroo states a 90% ultraviolet block, the Shade&Beyond states 90% sun block, and the ABOSUN states 90% ultraviolet protection.

Which featured cloth has the longest stated warranty?

The Coolaroo, with a 15-year warranty against ultraviolet degradation. The Shade&Beyond states a 5 Year Limit Warranty, and the winemana and ABOSUN listings state no warranty term.

How do the featured cloths attach?

The winemana hangs from grommets on each side every 40 inches, the Shade&Beyond hangs from grommets on each side every 2 ft with bungees, ropes and zip ties included, and the ABOSUN hangs from copper grommets every 1.8 ft with ropes and ties. The Coolaroo roll states no grommets and is cut to fit the space.

More from the barn

See every goat fencing guide and all fencing and shelter guides.

More picks: best hay feeders for goats, goat shelters and goat shelters.