Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Weld on vs Bolt on Gate Hinges: Which One Should You Buy?

Weld on vs bolt on gate hinges: when a welded joint wins, when bolts make more sense, and four weld-on hinge listings ranked by stated size, load and finish.

Weld on vs Bolt on Gate Hinges: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Insaga J Bolt Gate HingeInsaga J Bolt Gate Hinge9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Insaga 304 Stainless Steel Wall Mount Gate Hinges 2 PackInsaga 304 Stainless Steel Wall Mount Gate Hinges 2 Pack9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Insaga 304 Stainless Steel J Bolt Gate Hinge SetInsaga 304 Stainless Steel J Bolt Gate Hinge Set9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Heavy Duty Two Sealed Bearing Gate Hinge Weld onto the GateHeavy Duty Two Sealed Bearing Gate Hinge Weld onto the GateView on Amazon
  5. 5Weld On Hinges Heavy DutyWeld On Hinges Heavy DutyView on Amazon
  6. 6Heavy Duty Upgraded Sealed Bearing Gate Hinges Bolt or WeldHeavy Duty Upgraded Sealed Bearing Gate Hinges Bolt or WeldView on Amazon
  7. 7Weld on Hinges 3 InchWeld on Hinges 3 InchView on Amazon
  8. 8Heavy Duty Gate Hinges 1000 LbsHeavy Duty Gate Hinges 1000 LbsView on Amazon
  9. 92 Pack 3/4" J-Bolt Gate Hinges2 Pack 3/4" J-Bolt Gate HingesView on Amazon

Every gate on the place hangs on hinges, and choosing weld on vs bolt on gate hinges decides whether that gate still swings true after seasons of goats leaning, rubbing and pushing on it. This guide explains how the two mounts differ, when each makes sense, and what 4 weld-on hinge listings state about size, load rating and finish, since every example listing in this set welds on.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Weld on vs bolt on gate hinges: the short answer

Pick weld on hinges when the gate is steel, there is a welder on the place, and the gate will stay where it is: the Inchoco listing notes that welding eliminates screws and fasteners for superior strength, and the weld fuses hinge to gate. Pick bolt on hinges when there is no welder or the gate may need rehanging later: bolts come out and go back in, while a weld does not. All 4 listings in this guide are weld on hinges, so the bolt on side is described in general terms below.

How the two mounts differ

Weld on hinges join metal to metal with a weld bead. The Pixplex and BORDERSMOVER listings describe barrel hinges that weld to the gate and post, with grease nipples keeping the internal ball bearings lubricated. The Inchoco listing describes butterfly hinges welded directly to the door, and the Zonon listing describes bullet barrel hinges with a weldable hinge at one end. Once welded, the hinge does not adjust, so alignment has to be right before the weld cools.

Bolt on hinges fasten through holes in the gate frame and post with bolts and nuts. None of the 4 listings is a bolt on hinge, so no listing here states bolt sizes or hole patterns. In general terms, bolting needs no welder and the hinge can be unbolted for repair or adjustment, but the joint depends on the fasteners staying tight.

Four weld-on hinge listings, ranked

Ranked by stated specs, the BORDERSMOVER 4-pack leads with the most complete numbers: 450 lbs per hinge and 900 lbs per pair, a 0.6 inch barrel and 0.55 inch pin. The Pixplex 2-pack matches the 450 lb rating on a 5 inch barrel hinge, but its spec table disagrees with the title on length. The Inchoco butterfly set gives the most dimensional detail at 4.4 by 4 inches and 5 mm thick with 270 degree swing, but states no load rating and ships unfinished. The Zonon 10-pack offers the most hinges per box with 360 degree rotation, but states no load rating and its spec table calls the mount “Surface Mount” against a weld-on title.

Hinge Stated size Stated load Finish and mount
BORDERSMOVER 5 inch barrel, 4-pack 5 in; 0.6 in barrel, 0.55 in pin 450 lbs each; 900 lbs per pair Black powder coat; weld-on
Pixplex 5 inch barrel, 2-pack 5 in (spec table says 7 in) 450 lbs Matte black; weld mount
Inchoco 4.4 x 4 inch butterfly, 4 pcs 4.4 x 4 in; 5 mm thick Not stated Unfinished; weld on
Zonon 4 inch bullet barrel, 10 pcs 4 in Not stated Unfinished; title says weld on, spec says surface mount

BORDERSMOVER 5 inch barrel hinges, 4-pack

The BORDERSMOVER HG-209BK is the most completely specified hinge here: 5 inches long with a 0.6 inch barrel and 0.55 inch pin, a 1-1/2 inch mounting plate gap, and a stated 450 lbs per hinge or 900 lbs per pair. The black electrostatic powder coating is stated for rust and corrosion resistance, and a grease nipple keeps the ball bearings lubricated. No contradictions in this listing.

Pixplex 5 inch barrel hinges, 2-pack

The Pixplex listing describes a 5 inch barrel hinge in cold roll steel with a 1 inch barrel diameter and 1 inch back plate width, rated 450 lbs, with a matte black anti-rust coating and a grease nipple for the ball bearings. Flag the conflict: the spec table lists 7 inches long against the title’s 5 inches; the title and bullets agree on 5, so that is the stated size.

Inchoco 4.4 x 4 inch butterfly hinges, 4 pcs

The Inchoco WH is a weldable butterfly hinge about 4.4 by 4 inches and 5 mm thick, each hinge about 1.47 lb, with a stated 270 degree rotation. The listing’s pitch is the weld itself: weld the hinge directly to the door with no screws or fasteners for superior strength, per the maker. It ships unfinished and states no load rating.

Zonon 4 inch bullet barrel hinges, 10 pcs

The Zonon JAX-250331-A is a 10-pack of 4 inch bullet barrel hinges in carbon steel with a grease fitting, detachable, with a stated 360 degree rotation; the box weighs 3.5 lbs. Flag the conflict: the title says weld on hinges while the spec table lists the mount as “Surface Mount”; the title and bullets describe welding, so treat it as weld on per the title.

Match the hinge to the gate

Start from the gate’s weight and material, then the mount. The two 450 lb listings suit heavy steel swing gates and trailer ramps; the listings name swing gates, trailer gates and barrel doors. A 5 inch barrel hinge fits a different gate than a 4.4 inch butterfly, so measure the stile the hinge will weld to. Unfinished hinges ship without a coating, so plan for rust protection the listing does not state.

Read the listing twice

Two of the 4 listings contradict themselves. The Pixplex title says 5 inches while its spec table says 7 inches; the Zonon title says weld on while its spec table says surface mount. Trust the title and bullets over the spec table, and treat an odd spec-table figure as a listing error, not a feature.

What this guide does not cover

None of the 4 listings is a bolt on hinge, so bolt sizes, hole patterns and bolt-on load ratings are not covered here. Gate frame sizing, post setting and welding technique are beyond a hinge listing; welding takes equipment and skill, so a first weld on a gate is a job to learn on scrap, not on the gate.

FAQs from goat keepers

Are weld on hinges stronger than bolt on?

The Inchoco listing claims welding eliminates screws and fasteners for superior strength, which is the weld on side’s case in the maker’s words. No listing here states a bolt on hinge rating, so the bolt on side has no stated numbers to answer with.

What size hinge does a farm gate need?

The listings state 4 inch, 4.4 by 4 inch and 5 inch hinges. Match the hinge length to the gate stile and the load rating to the gate; the two 450 lb listings name heavy swing gates and trailer ramps.

Do weld on hinges need a welder?

Yes. Weld on means the hinge is fused to the gate and post with a weld, which takes a welder and the skill to lay a sound bead. Without one, a bolt on hinge is the practical choice.

Can these hinges hang a wooden gate?

None of the 4 listings states wooden gate use. The Pixplex, Inchoco and Zonon listings describe steel or metal gates, and the BORDERSMOVER listing names swing gates, trailer gates and barrel doors without stating wood. Match the hinge to a steel gate unless the listing says otherwise.

How much weight can these hinges hold?

The BORDERSMOVER and Pixplex listings state 450 lbs per hinge, with BORDERSMOVER adding 900 lbs per pair. The Inchoco and Zonon listings state no load rating.

More from the barn

See every goat fencing wire guide and all fencing and shelter guides.

More picks: best wire fence for goats, t post drivers for clay soil, welded vs woven wire fence and t post vs wood post.